Sunday, August 31, 2003

Homeowner's horror: sewage backups



Peter Bronson

Jay Hicks has an instant soup nightmare. Just add water, and his three-bedroom house on Kenker Place in Cheviot makes the Amityville Horror look like a model home in Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood.

Whenever it rains hard, his house is possessed by raw sewage. It backs up into his basement a foot deep, usually once or twice a year. This year, it's eight times and counting.

"It shoots up two or three feet in the air. It looks like a fountain down there," he says. "As soon as it starts, I ask my wife to get the kids and leave for two days while I clean the house."

The backyard also floods with raw sewage, creating a good environment for maggots and mushrooms, but not for children. "We just don't go out there," he said.

His problem is an extreme case. He was unaware when he bought the home - his first - that an old 30-inch combined main that carries sewage and storm water is just a foot below his basement floor. His 1933 house has four taps into the pipe - turning his basement into the "overflow tank'' for the neighborhood.

But Hicks is not alone on Backup Street.

"Its horrible, it's gross, it's unhealthy," said Hamilton County Commissioner Todd Portune. "There are thousands, even tens of thousands who have the same problem."

Rob Fredericks, an aide to Commissioner John Dowlin, called the problem "gigantic." He said the Metropolitan Sewer District has had about 2,500 complaints this year, but as many as 10,000 homeowners in the county have backups. "Three out of four don't report it because they want to sell their house someday, and they don't want a public record of having sewage in the basement."

Cheviot Safety Services Director Steve Neal says it's his worst problem. "It's their sewer, they should fix it," Neal said of the county.

Portune said, "I don't think there's any doubt the county has a responsibility here."

But Fredericks and Dowlin said they are both wrong.

A 1968 deal, approved by Cheviot, gave all storm water pipes to local municipalities, as the county took over sanitary sewers. In 1995, the county agreed to fix combined sewers, if local governments pay half.

"Mr. Hicks and all his neighbors would have no problem if Cheviot would live up to its responsibility," Fredericks said.

Neal said Cheviot can't afford half of $500,000 needed to fix the sewer line.

"Whether Cheviot can afford it or not is beyond me," Dowlin said. "But we have an agreement and we have to live by that."

He said it would be unfair to bill all ratepayers for Cheviot's problems. And thousands of homeowners could demand county repairs for their sewer backups.

Portune wants to change the rules at a meeting on Sept. 8. But Dowlin is right: Cheviot is on the hook.

The MSD is working on a plan to fix the Hicks home, Dowlin said. Or the county may buy it and build an overflow tank, so that homes nearby are not flooded, Fredericks said. "That stuff has to go somewhere."

"It's like beating your head against the wall," Hicks said.

He's trying to organize his neighbors to get Cheviot to pay for repairs. And he dreads the next rainstorm.

The scariest thing is not the geysers of sewage in his basement. It's the way public officials spout a fountain of raw excuses that smell worse than the stuff in Jay Hicks' basement.

E-mail pbronson@enquirer.com or call 768-8301.




SPECIAL REPORT: FORECLOSURES
Home schemes, broken dreams
High-interest loans jeopardized their home
Fliers and signs popping up on streets
Papers she can't read gave away her home
She owned, now rents family home of 100 years
Novice owner put faith in her former teacher
Lured into investing, left with shabby rentals
Subprime loans carry high risks, high rates

IN THE TRISTATE
Wet day may await Riverfesters
Unions put heat on Cintas
Key players in the fight over union
Labor Day picnic draws thousands
Township comes up short for monument
Church divided, still stands
Former minister vows to return
Homeless camp bulldozed for cars
Woman survives lightning strike
Falun Gong practitioners share story of imprisonment
Art comes outside, where the people are (walking)
Regional Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Pulfer: The Mighty Meatballs a lesson in school spending
Bronson: Homeowner's horror: sewage backups
Howard: Good Things Happening

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Township will see veterans exhibit
Family in the wrong district
Wal-Mart move stirs up West Chester traffic fears

OBITUARIES
William E. Haithcoat Sr., sports coach
John Roeder led Rising Sun schools
Kentucky obituaries

OHIO
Ohio bill takes cue from federal do-not-call list
Teacher accused of leading thefts
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Will candidates let it ride?
Kentucky News Briefs