Saturday, August 30, 2003

Doctor accused of unnecessary hysterectomies


Surgeon also faces 'branding' suit

By Murray Evans
The Associated Press

LEXINGTON - Women angered over hysterectomies they say were unnecessary filed lawsuits against Lexington surgeon James M. Guiler on Friday.

Guiler is also the target of a lawsuit filed earlier this year that claimed he branded "UK" - the initials of his alma mater, the University of Kentucky - into the uteri of women during hysterectomies. The lawsuits filed Friday are separate from the branding lawsuit, though one includes the couple who filed the branding complaint, Stephanie and David Means.

All three new lawsuits were filed in Fayette County Circuit Court and named Guiler; his employer, the Women's Care Center of Lexington, and Central Baptist Hospital of Lexington.

The first was filed by a Kentucky couple, Janet and Howard Hall, and the second by Gail Lewis. Both lawsuits also claim the women's' uteri were branded with the letters "UK" during operations.

Stephanie and David Means joined four other couples in the third suit.

"They were specifically told that the organs had to be removed," said Lexington attorney Sheila Hiestand, who said that pathology reports later indicated the operations were not necessary.

Donald K. Brown Jr. of Louisville, the attorney for Guiler and the Women's Care Center, said Friday afternoon he had not yet seen the lawsuits, but said they had no merit.

"We intend to aggressively defend every one of these claims because in virtually every instance, patients were referred by other doctors (to Guiler) with incapacitating pain, irregular periods, excessive bleeding and a suspicion of ovarian masses," Brown said. "They were all tried on conservative therapy without success, treatment options were discussed with each patient and the patient elected to proceed with the surgery."

The lawsuit included the Means' claims that the national average for hysterectomies performed per physician each year is 15, and that, by his own admission, Guiler performed 136 hysterectomies in 2002. Brown didn't dispute the latter number, but noted that Guiler was "a specialist in this area of medicine. Patients are referred to him."

Central Baptist Hospital spokeswoman Ruth Ann Childers said the hospital had no comment on the matter.

Plaintiffs in the three suits are seeking unspecified financial damages. Hiestand would not say whether the plaintiffs in the third lawsuit wanted Guiler to stop practicing medicine.




TOP STORIES
Kroger: New garage or we go
Big potential seen in long-ignored river

A QUESTION OF FAITH
Shaken, Catholics shunning church
Church spokesman believes in message
Nothing will shake her faith of 82 years
Elder High student's beliefs not affected
As a teen, he left the church
He believes in ideals of the Catholic faith
Victim abandoned dream of priesthood
Men of the cloth can be creeps, she says
Want to share your feelings about your faith? E-mail us

IN THE TRISTATE
Two truck accidents cause headaches on highways (Photo gallery)
11 accused of participating in large cocaine, marijuana ring
Rental program freeze sought
Order restricts release of Bengals lawsuit information
Regional Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Bronson: Lynch is not a resident, and Lindner is not cheap
Howard: Good Things Happening
Faith Matters: Art show honors Mary
McNutt: Neighborhoods

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
AK Steel's the place to be
Subdivision opponents want land checked for lead
'Grandpa' keeps kids laughing
Glass sculptures stolen
Widened part of Kemper to open
Symmes group drops petition
Street on project's edge faces cloudy fate

OBITUARIES
Virginia Coffey fought against discrimination
Former osteopath William Houser made house calls to his patients
Kentucky obituaries

OHIO
Role of relay switches examined in blackout
Lawyer accused in drug-ring probe
Popular boy band no longer 'N debt to city of Columbus
Pharmacist gets 3 years for embezzling $1.2 million
Meter runs while judge blocks prison shutdown
Tiny village in jeopardy as new law takes effect
Woman, 105, donates $1.25 million for park
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Restaurant shootings called unrelated
Doctor accused of unnecessary hysterectomies
Covington bishop apologizes for abuse by 30 priests
Overcrowded jail prepares for busy holiday weekend
Longtime legislator will not run in 2004