Saturday, August 23, 2003

Murderer who killed woman, son loses appeal



The Associated Press

FRANKFORT - A man convicted of murdering his cousin and her 10-year-old son has lost an appeal of his conviction and death sentence to the Kentucky Supreme Court.

A jury found that Melvin Lee Parrish stabbed Rhonda Allen and her son, LaShawn, to death and wounded a second son, 5-year-old Jonathan, in a robbery Dec. 5, 1997.

He got the death penalty for killing LaShawn, life without parole for killing Allen, life for attempted murder and 50 years for robbery.

In his appeal, Parrish claimed that Jefferson Circuit Judge Lisabeth Hughes Abramson was wrong to have permitted the jury to hear autopsy evidence that Rhonda Allen was pregnant.

Writing for the majority, Justice Donald Wintersheimer said the pregnancy "was not sensational or shocking or likely to induce any undue sympathy" for the victims.

In a dissenting opinion, Justice Janet Stumbo said it was "a reasonable presumption" that Parrish would be characterized "as the murderer of a mother and her unborn child and that such a characterization would have an undue prejudicial effect."

Justice Martin Johnstone joined in the dissent.

In a third opinion, Justice James Keller also said evidence of Allen's pregnancy should have been excluded but was not prejudicial.




TOP STORIES
Red Planet almost in spitting distance
Pit bulls in doghouse again
North Bend's existence in hands of voters
Norwood as 'medical mecca'

IN THE TRISTATE
Tony Orlando pinch-hits at Taste
In a new century, the dream is the same
Cemetery wants its deer departed
Search for the big gun pays off
Picture of the day: Moving in, a first-day ritual
In your schools
Regional Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Bronson: P.C. history repeats: First Miami, then Anderson
Howard: Some Good News
Faith Matters: Mothers bond together

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Chance to dunk officials nets $1,000 for United Way
Abandoned box put cops on terror alert
Countryside YMCA to celebrate 25th anniversary
Party starts school year
6-month hunt for killer ends

OBITUARIES
Dick Pike jazzed up radio's small, but legendary, WNOP
William Tepe was doctor 50 years
Charles Woeste lineman for 34 years

OHIO
New academy trains flight nurses
Expanded methadone treatment considered
Woman stabbed after saying no to beggar
Heavy-duty stretchers carrying increasingly heavy-duty patients
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
School celebrates 30 years of growth
House washed away; boy dies, two missing
Slots-at-tracks proposal likely to have easier time
Crossing guard hit by car outside school
Man gets 14 years for death of toddler
Murderer who killed woman, son loses appeal
Company of soldiers is home from Afghanistan
Ky. fair good this year; centennial will be great
Kentucky obituaries