Wednesday, August 13, 2003

U.S. House investigates 6th Circuit Appeals Court



By Malia Rulon
The Associated Press

WASHINGTON - The House Judiciary Committee is investigating the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati after complaints that rules were manipulated to affect a death penalty case and a University of Michigan affirmative action case.

The appellate court judges publicly differed in opinions involving the death penalty case of John W. Byrd and the affirmative action case involving admissions policy at the University of Michigan Law School, both of which reached the U.S. Supreme Court.

Afterward, an ethics complaint was filed against Chief Judge Boyce F. Martin Jr., with one of Martin's colleagues, Judge Alice Batchelder, saying Martin bent the rules in those cases.

The complaint was resolved by a judicial panel on July 31. However, Judicial Watch, a conservative Washington-based group, says the merits of the complaint were not addressed.

The group has asked the House Judiciary Committee to impeach Martin, saying disciplinary action still should be taken.

"We're asking the House to start impeachment proceedings," said Larry Klayman, chairman and general counsel for the group. "That should serve as an example to other judges that there shouldn't be any monkey business on the bench."

House Judiciary spokesman Terry Shawn said he could not provide any additional information on the inquiry because most of the committee's staff was on vacation.

The Senate is not pursuing an investigation.

The rancor among justices of the 6th Circuit isn't new. In the latest spat, justices disagreed over who would be allowed to vote on the decision to uphold the execution postponement of convicted killer Richard Cooey of Akron, Ohio.

Cooey was spared 12 hours before his July 24 execution because U.S. District Judge Dan Aaron Polster said Cooey's lawyer needed more time to study the case. The lawyer had been appointed to the case just three days earlier after the 6th Circuit fired his previous attorneys on June 10.

Judge Danny Boggs complained that his colleagues manipulated the rules to stop the execution.

The 6th Circuit handles appeals from Ohio, Kentucky, Tennessee and Michigan. A spokesman for the court was not available.




TOP STORIES
Cleaning water beneath Fernald will take longer
Norwood blight fight heats up
Elder removes priest's picture
Covington Diocese priest in child-sex case defrocked
College quiz 101: What's your major?

IN THE TRISTATE
Chesley aims to combine lawsuits
Spay/neuter program receives $20K grant
Here's chance to see old Woodward
Robber hits Carthage savings and loan, flees
Picture of the Day: Freedom Center Rising
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Bronson: Hannity shows the other side of the boycott story
Korte: City Hall
Howard: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
I-75 Liberty Twp. exit seems likely
Clermont seeks public advice on Metro bus routes
Butler trustees postpone rezoning for new complex
Computers in cruisers will aid Mason officers
UC adds presence in Warren
Decision on voting machines delayed

OBITUARIES
William G. Thornton, 89, built $10M firm
Lawrence Daily owned Swisher's department store

OHIO
U.S. House investigates 6th Circuit Appeals Court
Cleveland-to-Canada ferry service studied
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Former city councilman convicted of solicitation
Major gets life term in '80 slaying
Festival of Speed includes ballpark
Grant Co. gets West Nile case
Kentucky obituaries