Tuesday, August 5, 2003

Man found competent for trial in '74 death

By Janice Morse
The Cincinnati Enquirer

HAMILTON - After two years of legal wrangling, James Elmo Craft has been found competent to stand trial for the 1974 killing of a Springdale teen.

Butler County Common Pleas Judge Patricia Oney on Monday ruled Craft was competent to stand trial after defense lawyers Mark Conese and Michael Shanks agreed with a mental-health professional's conclusion that Craft understands the proceedings against him and is capable of assisting in his own defense.

But Conese and Shanks are still asking several questions, including:

• Was Craft, who has undergone four decades of mental health treatment, sane at the time of the crime?

• How can his mental state at the time be established now, 29 years later?

• Are authorities relying too heavily on statements from Craft to implicate himself?

Oney said she will decide whether the case must be thrown out only after hearing testimony at trial, which she set for Dec. 9.

Shanks said he thinks prosecutors have no physical evidence tying his client to the death of Cynthia Delores Beuerlein. The 15-year-old Springdale girl's body was found in a ditch at Rialto and Beckett Roads, in what is now West Chester Township, on June 13, 1974. She had been beaten.

Craft is already serving up to 25 years in prison for the 1988 voluntary manslaughter of his wife, Ruth Craft, a Fairfield West Elementary School teacher who was shot to death.

In 2001, about 18 months after the Butler County Sheriff's Office reopened the case, he was arrested and charged with aggravated murder in Beuerlein's slaying.

Shanks said he thinks that statements Craft made to investigators and jailhouse snitches form the foundation of the prosecution's case - and, if so, that's cause for concern.

Assistant Prosecutor Dan Eichel declined to respond to Shanks' comments. But he did say the prosecution's case was based upon "witness testimony."

If convicted in Beuerlein's death, Craft could receive a life sentence with parole eligibility in about 16 years.


E-mail jmorse@enquirer.com

Pulfer: Justin's case
Korte: Inside City Hall
Howard: Some good news

Ventura won - could Springer?
DeWine to see slaves' trail
Opinion sought on Web access
Truck driver dies on I-471 despite valiant rescue effort
Meet police, eat at crime 'going-away' parties
DNA evidence leads to arrest
Clermont to consider MRDD levy
Man found competent for trial in '74 death
Girls coach arrested on sex charges
Hamilton eatery hopes for revival
Votes today decide school, fire levies
Zoo's later summer nights hit with heat-weary visitors
Charges halt vote on gay bishop
Area leaders push unity in gay bishop debate
Bishop's letter to the diocese
Millions hanging up on landline phones
OSU arson suspect denied bail
Firefighter dies after pet viper bites him
Heavy rain, lightning riddle Ohio
Tristate A.M. Report
Teacher Bethany Kauffman helped children to read

Dad convicted; two children glad
Heavy rains flood Eastern Kentucky counties
Jim Beam warehouse incinerated
Petition calls for official's removal
West Nile found in Boone Co. mosquitoes
Fencing off 2 reservoirs worries some
Erlanger man dies in wreck