By Jane Prendergast
The Cincinnati Enquirer
People living under Cincinnati bridges got a temporary reprieve from eviction Friday when lawyers went to federal court, accusing the city of a pattern of unconstitutional attacks on the homeless.
Chris Roberts, 36, sleeps under the I-75 overpass near Third Street on the downtown's west side.|
(Steven M. Herppich photos)
| ZOOM |
A hearing was set for Monday on a temporary restraining order which, if successful, could keep police from moving the people out while the court case is pending. But the lawsuit goes beyond that, alleging that the city's two anti-panhandling laws also are unconstitutional.
Officers had prepared to roust the homeless Friday afternoon after No Trespassing signs were posted under the bridges Tuesday. Police had given the homeless 72 hours to gather their belongings and leave. By Friday afternoon a crowd gathered along Third Street near the Clay Wade Bailey Bridge, where activists, social workers and reporters outnumbered the five homeless people who live there.
The removal was delayed when a lawyer arrived about 2 p.m. with legal documents to sign for Don Henry, the unofficial leader of the homeless group.
Henry wouldn't say how he hooked up with the legal help. "I'm smart."
The lawsuit alleges that the city's two anti-panhandling laws and its plan to remove the homeless people violate five constitutional amendments, including those that promise rights to free expression, equal protection under the law, due process and freedom from unlawful search and seizure.
"It's their right as citizens to live where they want to live," said attorney Jennifer Kinsley, of the law firm Sirkin, Pinales, Mezibov & Schwartz. The firm is known for civil rights work.
People came out to support the homeless who sleep under the bridges and to protest plans to evict them Friday.|
| ZOOM |
Similar debates have played out in cities across the country. In Miami Beach a lawsuit is pending over the city's decision to outlaw panhandling in part of the business district. Advocates for homeless people say such laws only criminalize homelessness.
Last year in Cincinnati, lawmakers made it illegal to aggressively panhandle at bus stops and near ATMs. Then in June, City Council passed another law requiring panhandlers to get licenses, a measure modeled after a similar one in Dayton, where Cincinnati City Manager Valerie Lemmie previously worked. Police had been holding off on enforcing that law, allowing panhandlers an unofficial grace period to get their licenses.
Mayor Charlie Luken said Friday's challenge was expected.
"We had no intention of cracking down at 1 o'clock and causing a huge scene," he said. "We've tried to do this in a sensitive way."
The issue became public several weeks ago after Luken complained about a tent erected by a homeless couple living under the highway along the Interstate 71 exit ramp onto Third Street. He asked police to do something.
That touched off a debate over jurisdiction between the city and the Ohio Department of Transportation, which owns the under-bridge property. That was resolved by a July 9 letter in which ODOT's chief legal counsel said the city had the authority to remove people from the state's right-of-way and that the state had no objection to the city enforcing any law on ODOT property.
At the tent encampment that caught Luken's eye, Goodwill Industry workers picked up panhandler Richard Witherspoon and his wife Friday morning and took them an extended-stay hotel in Sharonville for a week and bought them $117 in groceries. Starting Monday, Goodwill will try to help them find jobs and housing, said Bruce Keller, special projects supervisor.
"They were very excited," he said of the Witherspoons. "I didn't hear one negative thing from either of them."
Witherspoon has been panhandling in Cincinnati for at least six months, saying he's a trained chef who was trying to collect money for a bus ticket to Cleveland.
The Greater Cincinnati Coalition for the Homeless' most recent count of homeless people in the city found 1,280 in shelters the night of May 21 and 196 on the streets.
City offer $18M shy of Convergys' liking
Text of Convergys letter
Ohioan top choice to lead UC
Court gives under-bridge squatters temporary delay
Get out there and enjoy the weather
IN THE TRISTATE
Artist's creativity bursts forth
Voting machines to be replaced
Picture of the day: Salute to a Soldier
Tristate A.M. Report
Faith matters: Students turn beliefs into service
BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Who wears short shorts? Not Fairfield students
Fairfield group to get data on flood control
Mother's wish fulfilled: Both sons come home
Butler meth lab dismantled
Funds sought for new school
Pair charged in bank holdup
Art auction helps cancer patients
Rev. Craig Edwards was pastor of year
Ohio, Calif. suing AOL Time Warner
Ex-mentor convicted in sex case
Lawmakers OK compromise on student-tally proposal
Teen charged in fireworks injury
Freed prisoner was wrongly convicted
Home-care nurses strike over hours, paperwork
Marathon sued over pipeline dispute
Hotel industry fights bed-tax increase
Flight festival has ups, downs
Cafes hope music drums up business
Ky. funding decision for farmers market delayed
Mexican consul wants ID accepted
Inmates plead guilty to assault
Ky. to put tobacco settlement into farms
Flood leaves girl awash in faith
Movie excites 'horse country'
Backstreet Boy aims to sell advice
Latter-day pioneers trek through state