Wednesday, June 25, 2003

Ryland settles second lead suit


Another family may add to spate of lawsuits over contamination

By Jennifer Edwards
The Cincinnati Enquirer

LIBERTY TWP. - Ryland Homes settled a lawsuit on Tuesday with a second Lexington Manor family over lead and arsenic contamination in their yard.

The settlement, which was not disclosed, came one day before a Butler County Common Pleas Court judge was expected to rule on whether Drew and Tara Dilley had to continue making monthly payments on their $234,400 home.

Lexington Manor has been declared a U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Superfund site. A cleanup should start this summer.

The Dilleys plan to move as soon as possible. They were joyous Tuesday over the settlement, saying that their daughter, Elyse, 3, soon can play in a clean, safe yard.

"It's great, a great relief," Drew Dilley, 34, said. "It's just been really rough and even though Elyse probably doesn't realize what's going on, it hasn't been fair for her. No child should have to live in a Superfund site."

Ryland has offered most residents the original purchase price of their home, $15,000 in additional expenses and $10,000 off their next Ryland house, should they choose to purchase one.

Drew Dilley could not discuss the terms of his settlement Tuesday. But he recently told the Enquirer he wasn't happy with Ryland's first buyback offer and wanted more money so they could purchase a comparable home nearby and to cover attorneys' fees.

Twelve other lots are contaminated and more might be discovered, according to the EPA.

A Ryland spokeswoman did not return calls Tuesday for comment.

Meanwhile, more Lexington Manor families might sue Ryland. On Tuesday, the Dilleys' attorney, Rob Croskery of Mason, was retained by AnneMarie and Colin Hester. Croskery said he expects to file a lawsuit on their behalf soon against Ryland and others involved.

Earlier this month, the Dilleys' neighbors, Ed and Robin Lumbert, also settled with Ryland one day before they were due in court to ask a judge rule that they didn't have to keep making their house payment.

Eighteen families remain who have sued Ryland over the contamination. Lexington Manor was built on 26 acres off Millikin Road that used to hold a skeet shooting range.

E-mail jedwards@enquirer.com.




TOP STORIES
Area is lucrative for Bush and GOP
Going outside today? Just don't breathe in
UC raises tuition by 10 percent
Lawmakers shelve racetrack slots idea

IN THE TRISTATE
Apartment fire kills visitor
Colerain establishes curfew law
Fair beefs up with new facilities
Ex-UC hoops player Donald Little gets jail
Obituary: Jim Rockwell led surgical laser use
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
BRONSON: City's law on pit bulls is a toothless Chihuahua
SMITH AMOS: Kaleidoscope of friends biggest lesson of college
HOWARD: Some good news

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
First on trial in prank gets jail
No tax, Monroe council is told
Board may hire political strategist
Ryland settles second lead suit
Fairfield citizens still can't vote on justice center
Board leader decries opposition
Sycamore assistant hired as Kings school superintendent

OHIO
Chances of school funding appeal dim, analyst says
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Boone County OKs 'bare bones' budget
Feds leave prosecution of Epling to state
Politicians hustling to fill war chests
Hebron student among $20K scholarship winners
Honoring Dr. King to be hearing topic
Wiedemann view lures N. Ky. home show again
Kentucky obituaries