By Gregory Korte
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Cincinnati City Council members say they have no choice but to pony up $15 million to build a parking garage for the Kroger Co. in order to keep the company's headquarters downtown.
But they don't have to like it. Members of the Finance Committee had some tough questions Monday about the proposed garage at Vine Street and Central Parkway. Among them:
What guarantees are there that Kroger will stay downtown?
Why didn't Kroger tell the city about its impending parking crisis sooner?
Why will the 1,000-car garage cost $15,000 a space, when suburban projects are spending half that?
"I'm going to support this, because the bottom line is that Kroger is simply one of the most important assets this community has," said Finance Committee Chairman John Cranley. "I don't think it's any surprise that the deal itself isn't anything to rejoice about. I don't think I got straight answers to any of my questions."
City Manager Valerie Lemmie is proposing an 850- to 1,000-space garage. Kroger would pay $510,000 - essentially, the annual operating cost - with the city picking up $1.4 million to $2 million in annual debt payments.
The city's portion would be financed, in part, by higher rates at city owned lots downtown - meaning the end of three-hour, $1 parking.
A provision of the deal gives the parking deck to Kroger - and requires the company to take over debt and maintenance payments if Kroger leaves town.
Mayor Charlie Luken said the clause is intended to give Kroger a gradually decreasing incentive to stay - and allow the company to find a tenant for the 44-year-old Kroger Building by linking the parking to the building.
But Cranley wondered if that wouldn't help Kroger leave town.
CEO Joseph A. Pichler said the May 6 passage of the $480 million school bond levy - and the resulting plans to build a school on a parking lot near Washington Park in Over-the-Rhine - precipitated the parking crunch.
Cranley wanted to know why Kroger never mentioned that fact when it was supporting the bond levy.
"Did you feel no obligation to tell us this would cost us $15 million - in addition to the additional property taxes for our residents?" Cranley said.
City Council will vote to approve the deal in principle Wednesday, with a decision on a more specific financing plan expected in August.
Howard: Some good news
Korte: Inside City Hall
Pulfer: The ambassador
SCOTUS RULING: AFFIRMATIVE ACTION
Court upholds principle, strikes down quotas
Local colleges step up minority recruiting
Local college-bound teens divided on vote
Tristate: Race matters
Putting the court's ruling into context
Bush: Diversity, not quotas, won
Excerpts from the court's two cases
Editorial: For the good of diversity
Guest column: Colleges face new confusion with court's guidelines
Local voices: Affirmative action ruling
Reserves receive hero's welcome
Butler Co. closer to relief from flooding
Fairfield can't stand the rain
Taxpayers stuck with Kroger's $15M bill
Mercedes-Benz looking at West Chester
2 motorcyclists die, another hurt in wrecks
Heberle parents demand information
School teams to be split up
Scholarship winners want to help others
CPS unveils two new designs
Calling all canoeists: Prove your skills at Paddlefest
West Chester committee urges recreation levy
Police sort information on river deaths
Parents who owe support offered catch-up chance
Death-row inmate asks for new trial
Obituary: Mary Louise Schum won design awards
Tristate A.M. report
Development of Ft. Mitchell farm OK'd
NKU grant may spur more health centers at schools
Video shows off city quirks
Needy parents on long waiting list for state child-care benefits
Ky. educators weigh state, federal testing at schools