Tuesday, June 17, 2003

Vandal gets 6 years in prison, tongue-lashing from judge

By Sharon Turco
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Judge Ann Marie Tracey didn't mince words. "(There's) a streak of sadism in your behavior that's very concerning to me," she told Mark Holtman Monday in Hamilton County Common Pleas Court. "...You're mean, you did damage for the sake of the thrill."

Then she sentenced the 20-year-old Colerain Township man to six years in prison for throwing a chunk of concrete at a vehicle on Springdale Road, seriously injuring a 17-year-old driver.

The evening of Oct. 29 was not the first time concrete had been tossed on the road, the judge said. Hamilton County workers reported that they often had to tow cars from the area - until Holtman's arrest.

Tracey said she'd been told that Holtman had tripped legally blind children and once tried to push someone in a wheelchair down a flight of stairs.

"You've got a streak running through you, a major problem," Tracey added. "Right now you're a threat to society."

Holtman was found guilty in May of two charges of felonious assault for seriously harming Scott Hoffman. He could have faced a sentence between 3 to 8 years in prison.

Three years was too lenient a sentence because Holtman's actions were intentional, Tracey said.

Hoffman, a Northwest High School junior, was driving the family van when Holtman hurled a large piece of concrete onto the road from a nearby creek bed. It smashed through the windshield, striking Hoffman in the head and knocking him unconscious.

His younger siblings gained control of the vehicle and crashed it into a vacant building to stop it. They were not injured.

But Hoffman suffered a traumatic brain injury, spent 17 days in intensive care, followed by another three weeks at the Drake Center. He's done with physical therapy, but continues with speech therapy to help him think faster and regain his memory.

Monday, Holtman's attorney, David Parker, called his client's actions, "impulsive, reckless and foolish."

Then, Holtman apologized.

"I am truly sorry for all the pain and suffering I caused," Holtman told the judge. "I hurt my family and (the Hoffman) family."

Assistant Hamilton County Prosecutor Lisa Rabanus said, "I disagree that this was an impulsive act. He'd done it before. This time the damage was much greater than in the past."

Hoffman said his attacker deserves to spend six years in prison. If he had anything to say to Holtman, he said it would be to "think before acting."

Hoffman's doctor has given him the OK to reapply for a driver's license and he's thinking about his Eagle Scout project again. He has six months to complete it.

His parents, Charles Hoffman Sr. and Ramona Hoffman, said they know their son can do it.


E-mail sturco@enquirer.com

Kids get down and dirty outside
Pulfer: Unexpected gifts

Flooding recedes, clean-up begins
Despite deluge, area's rainfall below last year
No respite for Butler flood crews
They log on, look out with Web crime cams
Church tosses defiant minister

Hamilton County
Butler County
Warren County
Clermont County
Northern Kentucky
Dearborn County

T's wife: 'I hate this area'
Liberty manager gets pay increase
Butler's monkeypox hot line is ringing
Home of Reds to become host for a day of prayer
Former sheriff sued by state
Council favors property tax cut
Decision changes parole system
Schools try to cope with Ohio budget cuts
Suspect in killing no longer a guardian
Traffic snarled, 2 hurt in wreck on Norwood Lateral
Assistant now Badin High School principal
Police give advice with fishing time
Mayor takes heat for budget mess
Portman among Ohio's richest lawmakers
Vandal gets 6 years in prison, tongue-lashing from judge
Tristate A.M. report

Board scours community center site
70 lawmakers to visit N.Ky.
Ky. athletes off to Special Olympics
Fort Thomas schools settle complaint case
Road projects may be halted