Saturday, June 14, 2003

Teens may need OK to get The Pill


Under proposal, minors need permission for birth control

By Cindy Schroeder
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Minors seeking The Pill and other birth control at federally funded clinics could only do so with their parents' consent under a proposal before Congress by U.S. Rep. Ken Lucas, a Boone County Democrat.

The Parents Right to Know Act of 2003 would require clinics receiving federal Title X money for birth control to notify parents at least five business days before any contraceptive drugs or devices are prescribed to a minor.

"All parents have the right to know if their child is receiving contraceptive drugs, especially if the federal government is subsidizing them," Lucas said. He and Congressman Todd Akin, a Missouri Republican, are co-sponsoring the legislation.

Last fall, the Northern Kentucky public health board backed similar legislation that was defeated in Congress.

Just months earlier, some board members tried to make their agency the first in the nation to reject federal Title X dollars for family planning services on the basis that birth control pills can cause abortions. That was defeated 14-13, with then-board chairman Greg Kennedy casting the tie-breaking vote.

"Last Aug. 28 we sent a letter to Congressman Lucas asking him to pursue (parental consent legislation)," said Dr. Charlie Kenner, a Florence dentist who is chairman of the Northern Kentucky Independent District Health Board. "I guess this is the way he has responded. We're very pleased."

Kenner said society sends contradictory messages to teens when it comes to getting parental permission on health issues. "Students in upper middle school have to go to the office to get a Tylenol," he said. "You have to be 18 to get your ears pierced without parental permission. Yet teenagers can go to a local clinic and get powerful hormones."

Anyone under 18 seeking birth control at federally funded clinics would have to get written permission from a parent or legal guardian, according to the legislative proposal introduced this week. Exceptions could be granted if the minor is emancipated, or a court has directed the minor receive the birth control.

Lucas said that birth control drugs can carry serious health risks. For example, he said contraceptives such as DepoProvera can kill teenagers with heart conditions.

Spokeswomen for the Northern Kentucky public health department and Planned Parenthood of Cincinnati said that teenagers served by their clinics had not experienced any serious side effects from Depo or other birth control.

In 2002, 16 percent of the patients receiving federally funded family planning services at Northern Kentucky's public health clinics were under 18, said Peggy Patterson, spokeswoman for the health department.

Cincinnati's Planned Parenthood program provided birth control to 1,841 people under age 18 last year, or about 9 percent of its clients, said Sue Momeyer, CEO for the Planned Parenthood Cincinnati region. "There are a number of areas, such as drug counseling, in which teens aren't required to get parental consent if not getting the treatment would be harmful," Momeyer said. "I think this proposal would be very harmful to teenagers and to society."

She cited a 1993 study in The Journal of the American Medical Association that found most high school students would not seek birth control or other care related to sexuality if they had to tell their parents. That study echoed an earlier one published in The Journal of Pediatrics.

Dr. Malcolm Adcock, Cincinnati health commissioner, said that he can sympathize with parents wanting more control over their minor children. "But I think the real control is working with your children early on to make sure they know where you stand on issues such as postponing sexual involvement."

E-mail cschroeder@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
With a soldier in Iraq, Father's Day will be quiet
Imax theater at Levee closes
Monroe tries to fix money mishandling
It's official: Ohio IS the birthplace of aviation

IN THE TRISTATE
Ballpark sign may notice city
Like Mother, Like Son
Grant gets more kids career training
Newest runway celebrated
Comedian tries to shake up youth
Old school makes way for homes
Program teaches kids using creativity
Experts: Turmoil still ahead for Justin
Report puts Ohio, Ky. high on mercury lists
Pathologist says bosses OK'd 'art'
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
GUTIERREZ: Beware the BFMs
RADEL: Memorial's their own labor of love
McNUTT: Neighborhoods
Faith Matters: Ballpark open for prayer

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
School warning of virus
Funding approved for traffic study
Milford woman killed in crash
Warren officials boost home lot sizes
Seniors drop from program on food quality complaints

OHIO
Molester evaded trial for 5 years
Innovative Jewish high school closing next year
Kent State University will bump tuition by up to 9%
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Teens may need OK to get The Pill
N.Ky. Visitors Center gets looks
Suspected human case of monkeypox investigated in western Ky.
Police nab suspect in meth factory case
Patton insurer loath to pay
Kentucky obituaries