Wednesday, June 4, 2003

Honor is predictor of college success


But smarts don't always pay off

By Cindy Kranz
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Valedictorians are a safe bet to become successful professionals, but don't expect to see them change the world.

"They're not the creative mold-breakers," said Karen Arnold, a professor at Boston College and author of Lives of Promise: What Becomes of Valedictorians (1995; Jossey-Bass).

"They're not the ones who are going to be Bill Gates. They're going to be good at running a division for Bill Gates."

Arnold followed 81 Illinois valedictorians and salutatorians from the Class of 1981 for 14 years. Arnold, who conducted the study with Terry Denny, a professor emeritus from the University of Illinois, found that valedictorians were generalists involved in many extra-curricular activities. They were persistent, conscientious, well-rounded and had a good work ethic.

"They knew how to do school," she said. "They attributed their success to working hard, doing their best and being willing to do what the school requires.''

It's a "fabulous predictor of college success. They graduated in record numbers. They won every award.''

The flip side about being so smart is that it doesn't always pay off.

"Harvard could fill itself with valedictorians, but it chooses not to," Arnold said. "They want divergent thinkers. ... They want those people who are going to break through in an unusual way."

After college, most valedictorians she studied went on to become professionals with high-level jobs, such as lawyers, doctors and leaders of companies and organizations, Arnold said.

"They're a good bet for future solid success, and they're solid people. Being valedictorian is part of their identity. ... There are very few labels that follow you through life. Valedictorian is one of them."




TOP STORIES
Stockbroker Donahue sentenced to 46 months
New gambling plan proposed for tracks
GOP Senate race could split party
Competition still keen to win top of the class
'You never know what can happen'
Catching up with past valedictorians
Honor is predictor of college success

IN THE TRISTATE
Family protests woman's care
Taft to speak at Cincinnati Country Day School graduation
UC faculty union votes to join new federation
Mayor of Norwood resigns post
Obituary: Eltee Watson, 106
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
AMOS: It takes a village
BRONSON: Maybe both
GUTIERREZ: Covington schools
RADEL: Volunteer's sequel after sequel
KORTE: City Hall
HOWARD: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Every owner of lead-tainted home gets a buyback offer
Schiavone gets job in Mason
Students pick best on prep stage
Woman charged with assault after cop chase
Charges against chief dropped
Shutoff notices alarm residents

OHIO
$140M added to budget plan
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Robbery suspect arrested
Suspect caught in Ind. after series of escapes
N. Ky. Community Center closes
Independence OKs $202,956 amphitheater
Kentucky News Briefs
Kentucky obituaries