Saturday, May 31, 2003

Court strikes part of school nepotism law



By Charles Wolfe
The Associated Press

FRANKFORT - Part of a nepotism law that prohibits people from serving on school boards if they have relatives employed by the school system is unconstitutional, the Kentucky Court of Appeals ruled Friday.

The court found that the law covers aunts and uncles but not nieces and nephews. That violates a constitutional guarantee of "equal protection" under the law, a three-judge panel said.

The decision upheld a ruling from Garrard County, where Greg Crutchfield successfully fought an attempt by the attorney general's office to remove him from the school board because his uncle was employed as a bus driver.

Crutchfield was elected in November 2000. Attorney General Ben Chandler's office filed suit in March 2001 to remove him.

The law states that no one with a "relative" working in the school district can serve on its board of education. It defines relative as father, mother, brother, sister, husband, wife, son, daughter, aunt, uncle, son-in-law or daughter-in-law.

Crutchfield claimed the definition was arbitrary because he would not be ineligible if the bus driver were his niece or nephew, rather than his uncle. The appeals court agreed.

"We are unable to discern the rational basis for the difference in treatment or classification of aunt/uncle and niece/nephew" in the statute, the court said in an opinion by Judge Matthew Baker of Bowling Green.

Rather than strike down the entire statute, the court struck only the references to aunt and uncle.

The Kentucky School Boards Association welcomed the ruling.

"We have thought since the (law) was passed that there was a tremendous incongruity," association spokesman Brad Hughes said.

"We hope it will allow some good folks on school boards to stay on school boards, especially in your smaller communities and smaller independent districts," he said.

In other cases, the court:

• Upheld a jury's order in Whitley County for an insurance company to pay $350,000 to a couple whose three children were killed in a highway crash in 1996.

The award against Globe American Casualty Co. was for bad faith and unfair claims practices. The company denied a claim by George and Carolyn Bowman for underinsured-motorist payments. Globe relented 11/2 years after litigation began.

• Upheld a Montgomery County judge's suppression of statements made by a Spanish-speaking suspect because an untrained interpreter gave him an unclear explanation of his constitutional rights.

The case involved Jose Antonio Orazco Sanchez. A court-appointed interpreter reviewing a record of Orazco Sanchez's interrogation found 48 instances in which the interpreter used by the police and sheriff added or omitted information, injected her opinion, changed or distorted what was said.

An excerpt from the transcript: "You have the right to consult any attorney, uh, before to make any conversation or any um, uh ... court that's going to involve it, uh, or to question, uh, any question."




TOP STORIES
Aquarium seeking $4.5M expansion
Domestic killing charge upgraded
Brace for temps in 40s

IN THE TRISTATE
Whittier Elementary's principal says farewell
Colerain looks at kids' curfew
Pandering conviction voided
Frampton to play game
Blue Ash deputy manager resigns
Obituary: Jeffrey L. Wise, 18, criminology major in college
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
GUTIERREZ: Family Leave Act
McNUTT: Neighborhoods
Faith Matters: Rabbi's twin in town for ceremony

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Springer stars in Butler Co.
Crash kills 2 in West Chester; driver charged
GOP calls off seat-switch
Fairfield trio take separate paths
Possible bomb in Union park

OHIO
Buckeye Egg cited by FDA for ignoring rules
Boy's family drops alternative method to treat leukemia
24-hour cameras watch Cleveland street for crime
Tank's success in Iraq reflects well on Lima factory
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Day camp meets the needs of kids who cope with cancer
Pendleton Co. investigates inmate abuse at Grant jail
Patton signs discrimination ban
Anti-smoking group brings fight close to home
Court strikes part of school nepotism law
Ky. Wesleyan president to step down
Students charged in huffing
Mine may account for bad water
Kentucky obituaries
More doctors face discipline
Critics upset by mining study
Fla. man files suit for abuse by Ky. priest
One person killed when blaze destroys mobile home
Justice joins Paducah environmental lawsuit