Thursday, May 29, 2003

Inmate freed by DNA accused of shoplifting



By Karen Gutierrez
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Less than a year after DNA evidence freed him from a 20-year sentence for rape, Herman May Jr. is back in trouble with the law.

The 32-year-old Frankfort man was arrested Friday on a shoplifting charge, Franklin County court records show. A Frankfort Kmart employee said May was caught stealing a portable CD player, stickers and magnets worth $94, the record shows.

May posted bond and was released. He did not enter a plea.

With help from two law students at Northern Kentucky University, May was released from prison in September after serving 13 years on a rape conviction. The students were part of the Kentucky Innocence Project, an effort by the Department of Public Advocacy to locate and test DNA evidence that might win the freedom of the wrongly convicted.

In May's case, new DNA information cast doubt on his guilt but fell short of proving his innocence. Franklin Circuit Judge Roger Crittenden set aside May's conviction, ruling that the evidence most likely would have resulted in his acquittal had it been available at the 1989 trial.

On Wednesday, Commonwealth's Attorney Larry Cleveland said he has not yet decided whether to retry May on the rape charge.

Friday's incident at Kmart is the latest in a string of legal problems May has faced since his release. He was arrested in December and again in March on marijuana possession and traffic-related charges, records show.

His attorney, Jerry Anderson of Lexington, said Wednesday he'll be negotiating a guilty plea for May in those cases. He will probably be fined and lose his driver's license, the attorney said.

His client "has some growing up to do," Anderson said.

"Herman's not used to being outside" of prison, he said. "I told his dad, 'You need to get him out of a car. This boy can't drive.' "

As for the possibility of a new trial on the rape charge, Anderson said the prosecutor, Cleveland, has offered to drop the matter if May pleads guilty to a felony - receiving stolen property - that occurred around the time of the rape in 1988.

Anderson said he and his client are still considering that deal. Cleveland declined to comment.

E-mail kgutierrez@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Docs here pioneers in new bypass surgery aid
Skaters roll out with less in wallets
Rescuers collect rare crayfish to save them
Budget plan outspends Taft

IN THE TRISTATE
City native still dreams of reaching the summit
A fancy dude in fancy duds
Mayor resigns county position
Mom's grief includes driver in son's death
Airport will have new trial to establish value of runway land
Obituary: Robert Dean, 65, FBI agent
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
PULFER: Lead hazard
HOWARD: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Mason in talks to get charges dropped
Inmate's guards may cost $300K
Voters to decide justice center issue
Mason invests in tracking students
Commissioners at odds over zoning changes
Township looks at zoning rules

OHIO
Former President Bush promotes son's economic plan
OSU to get $11M for tech center
Ft. Stewart remembers comrade
Inmate gets 10 years in plot to kill sister-in-law
Cafeteria will be scanning fingers
Man admits one slaying, not two
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Slaying not random act, mayor says
Inmate freed by DNA accused of shoplifting
Skate shop hopes to cater to cool crowd
Kids with wheels test-driving park
Water, sewer districts form security pact
Ky. computer programmer claims $9.6 lottery jackpot
Gay dads hope 2nd pregnancy calmer
Kentucky News Briefs