Saturday, May 24, 2003

Judges say legislative maps didn't discriminate



By John McCarthy
The Associated Press

COLUMBUS - The state board that redrew legislative districts for the 2002 election did not discriminate against minorities, three federal judges ruled Friday.

The panel unanimously upheld the plan approved in 2001 by the State Apportionment Board, dominated 4-1 by Republicans.

Legislative Democrats had sued the board, claiming it drew lines that suppressed the election of blacks in Ohio, and especially in four big-city counties: Franklin, Hamilton, Mahoning and Montgomery.

The Democrats did not prove the plan was drawn in a way that a white majority voting as a bloc could defeat a minority-preferred candidate, the judges said. The evidence the Democrats presented was "insufficient to show that the predominant factor in devising the redistrict plan was race," wrote Chief Judge Boyce Martin of the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

The board is required to redraw districts every 10 years to reflect population shifts found in the U.S. Census. Ohio law states the board must use the U.S. and Ohio constitutions and the federal Voting Rights Act as guides.

Republican consultant Scott Borgemenke drew the new lines in consultation with Floyd Johnson, the state redistricting director for the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People.




TOP STORIES
History preserved - by the people who made it
Library joins project to share interviews with war veterans
Alumni are solidly behind Elder
1,000 vehicles likely at funeral
Bellevue creates 'adult' zone

IN THE TRISTATE
Baseball fans still rooting for the home team
Women benefit from jail order
Police say theft ring thwarted
Six new priests to be ordained today
Mom and Dad abroad, gym crowd pitches in
Evendale confronts 'blight'
Memorial Day ceremonies
Memorial Day Closings
Obituary: Mary Julia Hanser, 61, past Mercy Health Partners CEO
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
CLIFF RADEL'S CINCINNATI: Life under the city
McNUTT: Neighborhoods
FAITH MATTERS: Soldier shares miracle

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Developer pays late impact fees
Parlor busted; who gets the case?
Classicway project gets approval

OHIO
Boehner misses 1:56 a.m. House vote for tax cut bill
Tight budgets stall efforts to offer home care
Judges say legislative maps didn't discriminate
Lawmakers listen to nursing homes
Boy, 9, killed when he touches light pole
Jury: Times libeled justice
Gynecologist charged with rape, sexual battery
Carnival baptisms draw complaints
Ex-inmate dies of apparent infection
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Library's WWI records online
Prison camp survivor to lead parade in Ky.
Court backs school site-based hiring
Reward offered for cemetery vandals
Trial July 18 in claim of assault at Grant Co. jail
Kentucky news briefs
Kentucky obituaries