Thursday, May 15, 2003

Convict guilty of riot murder



By Sharon Turco
The Cincinnati Enquirer

[photo]
Vallandingham

Ten years after Ohio corrections officer Robert Vallandingham was slain in a bloody prison riot at Lucasville, the last of four inmates charged in his death has been convicted.

Wednesday was the second time a Hamilton County jury found James Were, 46, guilty of kidnapping and of two counts of aggravated murder - one for plotting Vallandingham's death in the thick of the 11-day riot and the other for killing him during a kidnapping.

This time, though, Were may not face the death penalty because of a new U.S. Supreme Court ruling.

Were was convicted and sentenced to die in 1995 for Vallandingham's strangulation death, but in 2002 the Ohio Supreme Court overturned the conviction because Were had not been previously evaluated for competency to stand trial.

The new trial began April 29 and ended Wednesday afternoon after the jury deliberated for about a day.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty. But first, in a hearing Friday, they'll have to prove Were is mentally sound.

The U.S. Supreme Court changed the death penalty rules last June declaring executions of the mentally retarded "cruel and unusual."

The commonly accepted standard for mental retardation is an IQ of about 70 or below, including at least two lower-than-average abilities, such as communication.

Were's attorneys contend he is mentally retarded because he has an IQ of 69.

A psychologist testified about Were's low IQ during a pretrial competency hearing, as did a prison teacher.

Defense attorney Elizabeth Agar said the defense would introduce the same evidence Friday, including IQ tests Were took as a child.

If Were is found to be mentally retarded, guidelines call for a sentence of 30 years to life in prison.

Special Prosecutor Steve Tolbert said several legal briefs written by Were show he is mentally sound.

Were kidnapped Vallandingham on April 11, 1993, the day the riot broke out. Four days later he was one of several inmates who voted to kill a guard if inmate demands for food and water were not met, authorities say. Later that morning, Were ordered Vallandingham killed.

Peggy Vallandingham, the guard's widow, smiled at Wednesday's verdict for the first time since the trial began. Friends hugged her outside the courtroom.

Were showed no emotion.

E-mail sturco@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Moon takes spin in our shadow
High-tech detectors spot high waters
'Battered wife' charged in shooting
Quiet suburb jolted by neighbor's gun death
Two apartment buildings damaged in Elmwood fire

IN THE TRISTATE
Doll is flat-out amazing teacher
New roads connect ballpark, river, downtown
Northside unsafe, activist says
Beggars won't need to register
Few Heberle pupils test high for lead
Convict guilty of riot murder
Medical service abuse study proposed
Calling top high school seniors
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
PULFER: New money
HOWARD: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Builder removes pellets on curbs
Beer OK'd at VOA park festival, but bingo tent denied
2 courts dispute computer report
Clermont to cancel wastewater contract
Evendale blight fight rekindles
Middletown schools offer a choice of building plans
Petition effort called legal
Union Centre Blvd. needs fixing
Legal career over for former municipal judge
Shooting victim had been stalked
Springer to speak at Democratic fund-raiser

OHIO
Taft: Hone reading program
Mother of abandoned baby sought
Bond revoked for women in case of boys kept in closet
Guards' union delays closing of prison in Lima
$14M lottery jackpot slips away unclaimed
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Five to fill expanded rights panel
Man who led stolen-car chase indicted
Third man claims jail beating; his case won't be prosecuted
Poll has Chandler, Fletcher leading
Ky.-based soldier killed in Iraq
Miner buried alive gets out
Attorney general candidates hurl personal attacks
Suspect in dorm death accused of earlier assault
Kentucky obituaries