By Gregory Korte
The Cincinnati Enquirer
A proposal to register panhandlers in Cincinnati appeared to die in City Council on Wednesday night when supporters lost a key vote.
Councilman John Cranley, who voted for the plan in the Law & Public Safety Committee on Monday, said he "saw the light" and now believes the plan to be "fundamentally and totally flawed."
"It's a license to beg. It will create a permanent industry of panhandling in the city," Cranley said.
He said "scammers and schemers" would be first in line to get registered, hoping the license would convey an air of legitimacy to their activity. Those who are down on their luck and unable to afford bus fare would be most likely to run afoul of the law, he said.
Cranley also opposed a companion measure to spend $50,000 on a social service program to help panhandlers find shelter, food, jobs and substance abuse treatment. He said $50,000 to deal with only 30 problem panhandlers seemed expensive, and he worried that the program would set up "a permanent bureaucracy and advocate for panhandling."
The sponsors of the ordinance, Pat DeWine and David Crowley, hoped to bridge the ideological divide by combining the registration with the social services.
The registration proposal was modeled after a similar ordinance in Dayton, where merchants say it's been effective in curtailing the most abusive beggars.
DeWine said it would give downtown officers another tool to go after problem panhandlers by allowing the police to revoke their licenses, and then cite anyone begging without a license.
The registration system would also give social service agencies more information on the panhandlers and their needs, Crowley said.
But Cranley said another DeWine-sponsored measure enacted last year - which made it illegal to beg near automated teller machines, bus stops and store entrances - has already been successful in curbing the most aggressive panhandling.
Cranley joined Y. Laketa Cole, Minette Cooper, Chris Monzel and Alicia Reece in opposing the measure.
Not having the votes to pass the registration ordinance, DeWine sent it back to his Law Committee on Wednesday. Crowley said they would "build some more fire" under the ordinance and bring it back in a week or two.
But Mayor Charlie Luken, who had threatened to veto the $50,000 in spending on a social worker, predicted it would be holed up in the Law Committee forever.
"It's going to sit on the agenda right next to the item pricing proposal that Pete Strauss introduced in 1983," Luken said.
Moon takes spin in our shadow
High-tech detectors spot high waters
'Battered wife' charged in shooting
Quiet suburb jolted by neighbor's gun death
Two apartment buildings damaged in Elmwood fire
IN THE TRISTATE
Doll is flat-out amazing teacher
New roads connect ballpark, river, downtown
Northside unsafe, activist says
Beggars won't need to register
Few Heberle pupils test high for lead
Convict guilty of riot murder
Medical service abuse study proposed
Calling top high school seniors
Tristate A.M. Report
PULFER: New money
HOWARD: Some Good News
BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Builder removes pellets on curbs
Beer OK'd at VOA park festival, but bingo tent denied
2 courts dispute computer report
Clermont to cancel wastewater contract
Evendale blight fight rekindles
Middletown schools offer a choice of building plans
Petition effort called legal
Union Centre Blvd. needs fixing
Legal career over for former municipal judge
Shooting victim had been stalked
Springer to speak at Democratic fund-raiser
Taft: Hone reading program
Mother of abandoned baby sought
Bond revoked for women in case of boys kept in closet
Guards' union delays closing of prison in Lima
$14M lottery jackpot slips away unclaimed
Five to fill expanded rights panel
Man who led stolen-car chase indicted
Third man claims jail beating; his case won't be prosecuted
Poll has Chandler, Fletcher leading
Ky.-based soldier killed in Iraq
Miner buried alive gets out
Attorney general candidates hurl personal attacks
Suspect in dorm death accused of earlier assault