Saturday, May 10, 2003

Pathologist's conviction reversed


Judges cut Condon's punishment

By Dan Horn
The Cincinnati Enquirer

An appeals court on Friday threw out the conviction of a pathologist who was accused of helping Thomas Condon photograph bodies at the Hamilton County morgue without permission.

Condon
Condon
Tobias
Tobias
The court also reduced Condon's prison sentence from 30 to 18 months, concluding that he had been punished too severely for his crime.

Condon and the pathologist, Jonathan Tobias, were convicted last year of gross abuse of a corpse for taking photos of at least nine bodies posed with sea shells, fruit, toys and other objects.

The case generated national attention after Condon said he thought morgue officials had given him permission to pursue "an artistic endeavor" involving photos of corpses.

Both Condon and Tobias have argued that prosecutors made them scapegoats in order to protect high-ranking morgue officials from public embarrassment and possible criminal charges.

In its ruling Friday, the Ohio 1st District Court of Appeals agreed that prosecutors had acted inappropriately during the trial and had, at times, made "grossly unprofessional" remarks to the jury.

"The prosecutor's comments were highly inappropriate and constituted prosecutorial misconduct," wrote Appeals Judge Robert Gorman, who was joined in the opinion by Judges Mark Painter and Howard Sundermann Jr.

The appeals judges said the prosecution's conduct was unfortunate but not severe enough to overturn the convictions.

Instead, the appeals court focused on whether prosecutors presented sufficient evidence to prove either man's guilt. The judges said there was enough evidence against Condon, but not Tobias.

"There was no evidence that Tobias took an affirmative action to aid Condon," the judges concluded. "The most that can be said from the testimony is that Condon and Tobias were friendly with one another."

Tobias' attorney, Marc Mezibov, said the decision Friday vindicates Tobias and clears the way for him to regain his medical license. His license was suspended after his conviction last year.

"It was very clear that Dr. Tobias had done nothing wrong," Mezibov said.

Tobias could not be reached for comment, but his mother, Jean, said the decision shows that Prosecutor Mike Allen was wrong to pursue charges against her son. She said he was singled out for prosecution while others at the morgue avoided charges.

"The 1st District's decision exposes Mr. Allen's hypocrisy," Jean Tobias said. "There is justice after all in America. The truth does count."

Allen declined interview requests Friday but issued a statement expressing disappointment that Tobias' conviction was overturned. He said he was "gratified," however, that Condon's conviction was upheld.

Condon's lawyer, H. Louis Sirkin, said he will appeal the decision to the Ohio Supreme Court and will ask that his client be allowed to remain free on bond pending the outcome of that appeal.

Sirkin said he was disappointed the appeals court did not feel the prosecution's conduct was reason enough to toss out Condon's conviction. At one point during the trial, Chief Assistant Prosecutor Tom Longano referred to Condon's photos as a "bull---- project."

The case against Condon began in 2001 when police learned he had taken hundreds of photos of bodies at the morgue. Morgue officials said they had given Condon limited access to the morgue to do preliminary work for the production of a training video. But they denied any knowledge of his interest in an art project involving dead bodies.

Family members have since sued the county, claiming the negligence of morgue officials allowed Condon to get access to the bodies.

"The doctor got off too easy, but he's not the only one involved," said Cynthia Folchi, whose 19-year-old daughter was among those photographed by Condon. "And Thomas Condon should have gotten more time."

The appeals court reduced Condon's sentence after concluding that Judge Norbert Nadel erred when he decided Condon had committed the "worst form" of gross abuse of a corpse.

The court determined that Condon showed a "callow indifference" but not the "same degree of depravity" as others who have abused corpses.

In a concurring opinion, Painter suggested that a further reduction of Condon's sentence might be warranted, although the court did not recommend it.

"Condon surely is not a threat to do this again," Painter wrote. "A prison sentence of any length would be sufficient to impress upon him the wrong-headedness of his behavior."

E-mail dhorn@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Jammin' is laid-back street fest
Dancin' crowd helps festival pick up the pace
Pathologist's conviction reversed
College grads find dream jobs elusive
Hamilton soldier shot dead in Iraq

IN THE TRISTATE
Event honors traditions
Robbers hit bar; patron shoots
Obituary: Jean Angela Noppenberger, Sister of Charity
Tristate A.M. Report
Number of audits likely to grow
Fire captain accused in abduction
Hey west side, you're next

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
McNUTT: Author to lead writers' session
Faith Matters: Moms honored at area services

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Gas leak closes road by Lebanon
Suspect returns for trial in 1974 killing
Cleanup spoils summer
A snip for charity
Fugitive who owes victim imprisoned

OHIO
Victim receives $550,000
Pickerington parents propose pay-to-play to salvage activities
President picked for Cleveland Foundation
Ohio contests unemployment fine
Historic highway helped America grow westward
Boarder pleads guilty to murder of Mount Victory councilwoman
More animal farms avoid regulation
Bathroom passes ease wait for new coaster
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Land wanted by airport to cost $9.5M
Tired of your old tires? Now's your chance
Western regents OK joint engineering degree programs with UK and U of L
Murder suspect had violent history
Three charged for meth lab
'Probable' case of SARS being treated in N.Ky.
N.Ky. Rep. Lucas one of only four Democrats who voted for tax cut
Escapee gives up after tear gas lands
Court upholds dismissal of case against Mexican
WKU dorm fire, death prompts review of safety
Kentucky obituaries
Court rules in favor of W.Ky. industrial park bond issue
Child-support lawsuit targets candidate
Candidates spent $12.5M
Cleanup proceeding at Paducah plant