Saturday, May 10, 2003

Suspect returns for trial in 1974 killing



By Janice Morse
The Cincinnati Enquirer

HAMILTON - J. Gregory Howard was an eighth-grader in Louisville when Mildred Ruth Doench was killed in her Fairfield Township home.

Now, 29 years have passed, and Howard, an attorney for 15 years, has been appointed to defend Donald L. Korn, the man facing a retrial in Doench's slaying.

The 72-year-old retired elementary school principal died in one of Butler County's most unforgettably violent crimes. She was raped, stabbed and struck with a mattock, a hatchet-like tool that the killer left embedded in her forehead. It's also one of the oldest cases to be prosecuted.

"When you get a case this old, you've got witnesses who may no longer be around, or ones who don't remember things that well. You don't know where the evidence has been all this time, or how it's been handled," Howard said. "It makes it difficult for both sides."

Butler County Prosecutor Robin Piper agrees that decades-old cases present legal hurdles. But Piper said he's required to seek justice even when it isn't easy, even after almost three decades.

New, undisclosed evidence revived the case, leading officials to file a warrant for Korn's arrest in December. This week, after months of legal wrangling, Korn, a convicted rapist, was brought from an Indiana prison to the Butler County Jail. He is awaiting arraignment on an aggravated murder indictment that was filed in 1976.

"I've never had one pending this long," Howard said.

Korn is already 58 years old and serving a potential life sentence in Indiana. But Piper said he feels it's necessary to go forward because there are no guarantees that Korn will remain locked up. Indiana has denied Korn parole three times since he was convicted there in 1976, but another parole hearing is set for December 2005.

In Doench's case, Korn was previously convicted of killing her; he even had been scheduled to be executed.

But in 1978, the U.S. Supreme Court declared Ohio's death-penalty law unconstitutional, and the next year, an appeals court found Korn's confession was improperly obtained. The court reversed his conviction and said he was entitled to a new trial.

Without the confession, then-Prosecutor John F. Holcomb said he was left without a case. He made several unsuccessful tries to get the appeals court's decision reversed.

Finally, in 1993, Holcomb said he felt compelled to formally withdraw a "detainer," an order to hold Korn for potential prosecution by Ohio authorities.

But the indictment was never dismissed.

The case sat inactive until December 2001, when Butler County Common Pleas Judge Patricia Oney appointed Howard to represent Korn. That was many months after the Butler County Sheriff's Office reopened its investigation.

Last August, Korn filed a motion arguing for the 1976 indictment to be declared void because prosecutors didn't act on it quickly enough. He claims that violated an interstate agreement on detainers.

But prosecutors say that argument is moot because Korn didn't file papers to push for a conclusion.

Oney has not yet ruled on the motion to dismiss.

Korn cannot again face the death penalty, prosecutors say.

The now-unconstitutional death statute, in effect at the time of the alleged crime, would apply. So life imprisonment with the possibility of parole after 20 years is the harshest sentence Korn could get.

Still, Doench's son, Robert, who lives out of state, has said that a conviction would make it easier for him to focus happy memories.

E-mail jmorse@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Jammin' is laid-back street fest
Dancin' crowd helps festival pick up the pace
Pathologist's conviction reversed
College grads find dream jobs elusive
Hamilton soldier shot dead in Iraq

IN THE TRISTATE
Event honors traditions
Robbers hit bar; patron shoots
Obituary: Jean Angela Noppenberger, Sister of Charity
Tristate A.M. Report
Number of audits likely to grow
Fire captain accused in abduction
Hey west side, you're next

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
McNUTT: Author to lead writers' session
Faith Matters: Moms honored at area services

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Gas leak closes road by Lebanon
Suspect returns for trial in 1974 killing
Cleanup spoils summer
A snip for charity
Fugitive who owes victim imprisoned

OHIO
Victim receives $550,000
Pickerington parents propose pay-to-play to salvage activities
President picked for Cleveland Foundation
Ohio contests unemployment fine
Historic highway helped America grow westward
Boarder pleads guilty to murder of Mount Victory councilwoman
More animal farms avoid regulation
Bathroom passes ease wait for new coaster
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Land wanted by airport to cost $9.5M
Tired of your old tires? Now's your chance
Western regents OK joint engineering degree programs with UK and U of L
Murder suspect had violent history
Three charged for meth lab
'Probable' case of SARS being treated in N.Ky.
N.Ky. Rep. Lucas one of only four Democrats who voted for tax cut
Escapee gives up after tear gas lands
Court upholds dismissal of case against Mexican
WKU dorm fire, death prompts review of safety
Kentucky obituaries
Court rules in favor of W.Ky. industrial park bond issue
Child-support lawsuit targets candidate
Candidates spent $12.5M
Cleanup proceeding at Paducah plant