Thursday, May 8, 2003

Job applicant papers ruled not public record



By Spencer Hunt
Enquirer Columbus Bureau

COLUMBUS - The Cincinnati Enquirer is not entitled to resumes and other records that Cincinnati Public Schools officials used to pick their new superintendent, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled Wednesday.

The 6-0 decision states that documents the five superintendent finalists shared with CPS board members and a hired search firm in September were never public record. That's because neither the board nor the firm, Milwaukee-based Proact Search Inc., kept those papers on file.

"The definition of 'public records' unequivocally requires that the records be 'kept' by any public office," the justices wrote.

The seven-member CPS board unanimously voted to hire Alton Frailey, an assistant superintendent from Houston's Spring Branch Independent School District, on Sept. 6 after a secretive two-day interview process.

The five finalists were told that if they left any of their "application materials" with the board, they would become public record.

The Enquirer filed suit in October, arguing in part that the resumes and other papers should be shared with the public because they had been received by school board members.

Bill Seitz, CPS' attorney and a state lawmaker, said the ruling should offer some protection to school officials leery of letting their employers know they're looking for another job.

"Many qualified candidates for public office are reluctant to apply because of the mere fact of their applications becoming public knowledge," Seitz said.

Jack Greiner, the Enquirer's attorney, said the public has a right to know not only the qualifications of the person who was hired, but also of those people who were turned down.

"Did they pick the best person?" Greiner asked. "How can you tell that?"

E-mail shunt@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
For CPS students, teachers, levy first step to better digs
Black vote called key for issue win
Grocer removes barriers
Clovernook marks 100th year of opportunities for the blind
Fiorini indicted in fraud
Fletcher's campaign given green light by high court

IN THE TRISTATE
Supreme Court delays Campbell's execution
Condon called fixture at morgue
Council halts student housing project
Four indicted in petition falsification
Norwood cinches up its belt
Man's death sentence overturned
Job applicant papers ruled not public record
Obituary: Rev. John Compton, 77, served Christian Church
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
PULFER: YWCA luncheon
HOWARD: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Danger lurks in Dick's Creek
King's rethinks as levy defeated
EPA to detail cleanup of lead in Liberty Township subdivision
Petition legality under question
Complaints delay housing decision
Council OKs outline for economic development
Victim's injuries reminder of crime
City's plan ruffles county's feathers
Police Advisory Committee created

OHIO
Laci's family backs DeWine bill to protect fetuses
Fire in historic building ruled deliberate
How to decide who lives, dies?
New law lets Amish opt out of paying into workers' comp
Portman declines budget director post
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Covington says thanks to Bill Cappel with new sports complex
Engineer joins Boone planners
Mother of all YMCAs coming to Boone Co.
Covington nuisance law used for first time
Pendery withdraws from 4th District campaign
WKU student dies of dorm fire injuries
Judge hears evidence in slaying of 13-year-old
Another union urges CBS to can 'Hillbillies'
Five inmates in court in attack on teen
Former NKU foundation head pleads guilty
Kentucky obituaries