Tuesday, April 29, 2003

Boyfriend gets 35 years for killing



By Chris Mayhew
The Cincinnati Enquirer

NEWPORT - A 23-year-old Melbourne man was sentenced to 35 years in prison Monday in Campbell County Circuit Court for the murder of his live-in girlfriend, Carrie Smalling, on April 27, 2002.

The sentence for James C. Prichard was accepted by both the Commonwealth Attorney's Office and the defense in a plea bargain. Prichard will become eligible for parole after 20 years, including time already served.

Smalling, 21, of Silver Grove was shot twice with a .22-caliber gun, once in the head. Survivors include two small children, Ivy, now 4, and Courtney, 17 months.

Family members said Prichard is the father of Ivy, and that Prichard's best friend fathered Courtney.

At the sentencing, Smalling's two sisters sobbed as they read a statement directed at Prichard.

"You, J.C., you killed her execution-style. You pressed the gun between her eyes, knowing it would end her life," said her sister, Christina Crank, 21.

"I hope you think of it every night before you lay down," Crank said.

Crank said Prichard was part of their family; photos of her sister without him were hard to come by.

During her statement, Tisha Bowen said the hardest thing she ever had to do was to look at her sister in a coffin.

"She was young, and her smile could brighten a room," Bowen said.

Carrie Smalling's parents said they were not happy with the plea agreement because they wanted Prichard to go through a jury trial, despite the possibility he might serve less time.

"This plea bargain wasn't what we wanted," said John Smalling of Newport. "I think a jury would have given him more."

Commonwealth Attorney Jack L. Porter Jr. said he was satisfied with the plea agreement.

"It's always a risk when you go to trial that you're not going to get as much as you want," Porter said. "If I was sitting where the victim's families are, I would want more."

E-mail cmayhew@enquirer.com




"GREAT NEIGHBORHOODS" SERIES
Guide to Florence

TOP LOCAL STORIES
FOP might withdraw from collaborative
Light rail gets favorable review
Teen's body found under neighbor's bed
92-year-old loses license for fatal accident
Rights plan up for vote tonight

LAURA PULFER COLUMN
Learning to respect hand jive

PHOTOS OF THE DAY
Photo: Canoeing couple
Photo: Firefighter fans
Photo: Preparing the pool

CINCINNATI-HAMILTON COUNTY
Two plead guilty in plot to stop man from testifying
Lawsuit against Enquirer dismissed
Police chief stops knife fight
Best future lawyers at Oak Hills

AROUND THE TRISTATE
Convict's last meal: chicken, apple pie
Portman salutes troops after visit to hospital
Group adopts scale to chart Tristate vitality
Tristate A.M. Report
Good News: 'Taste of' offers view of India
Obituary: John Toebben coached soccer champs
Congrats

BUTLER COUNTY
1% cuts ordered for Butler County
Fairfield picks site for justice complex
School kids helped by foundation

WARREN COUNTY
Tax issues facing Warren Co. voters

OHIO
Lower drug prices for Ohio seniors
Spectacular fire engulfs marsh
Ohio Moments: 50,000 paid respects to Lincoln

KENTUCKY
Airport reduces ground infractions
Clues sought in restaurant slaying
Boyfriend gets 35 years for killing
Court won't decide on commandments
Doctor pleads guilty in drug case