By Gregory Korte
The Cincinnati Enquirer
The Cincinnati Black United Front should be allowed to bail out of the city's landmark police-community relations agreement - but only if their lawyers go with them, City Council members say.
If they do, the city would continue to work through the collaborative agreement on police-community relations, under a statement approved by the Law and Public Safety Committee Friday.
The most recent crisis facing the year-old agreement is the Black United Front's announcement last week that it no longer wanted to serve as the "class representative" for the class-action lawsuit on racial profiling, which led to the collaborative agreement. The group, led by the Rev. Damon Lynch III, said it wanted to focus on promoting a national boycott of Cincinnati to raise attention to police brutality and what it calls "economic apartheid."
Several national civil rights leaders are expected come to Cincinnati next weekend in an effort to escalate the boycott.
Councilman David Pepper said the Black United Front's continued promotion of the boycott was turning the collaborative agreement into a "farce."
Under City Council's resolution, which Pepper drafted, the city would only continue to work within the agreement if:
Remaining plaintiffs in the lawsuit that led to the agreement select a new class representative that is large enough and broad enough to reflect the black community. That entity "must not actively support the boycott," the resolution said.
Plaintiff's lawyers involved in the implementing the agreement no longer represent the Black United Front, or any other client suing the city for alleged violations of the agreement.
Though not mentioned by name, it was clear that City Council was targeting plaintiff's attorney Kenneth L. Lawson, whose practice almost exclusively includes criminal defense and civil rights cases against police.
Lawson called it the "Shut Ken Lawson Up Act."
"I will not be silenced. I will continue to represent people in cases against the Cincinnati Police Department," he said.
Another plaintiff's lawyer, Alphonse Gerhardstein of the American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio, accused the city of trying to pick its opponent in court.
Mayor Charlie Luken said the collaborative agreement was "doomed to failure" as long as those helping to improve police-community relations were also suing the police department and urging a national boycott of Cincinnati.
Other council members agreed. Pat DeWine and John Cranley said one of the goals of the agreement was supposed to be reducing crime. But the Black United Front has argued that arresting suspects should be a "last resort" to dealing with criminal activity, they said.
"The plaintiffs do have a commitment to reduce arrests. I'm not ashamed to say that. That doesn't mean we're in favor of crime," Gerhardstein said. "In state prisons, 54 percent are African-American, compared to 12 percent of the state population. That disparity isn't just explained by more crime being committed by African-Americans. It's explained by discrimination. We need to look at how we define crime and look at our measures to fight crime."
Steve Sunderland, a Northside activist who has been working on police-community relations from the agreement, said there was plenty of blame to go around. The city has done almost nothing to implement the agreement, he said.
Other activist groups were also critical of the Black United Front. At one point, public testimony at Friday's meeting turned into a gripe session by several splinter groups critical of the Front's role in the collaborative and the boycott.
"The problem has been the Black United Front. They have not represented the African-American community. The white power structure picked the Front to lead the community," said Nathaniel Livingston, who leads one of two groups calling itself the Coalition for a Just Cincinnati.
TRISTATE REACTS TO WAR
Mom's sons share Army bond
'Sister cities' say no tensions developing
West Chester firefighters help
Rally 'for the kids overseas'
Friendly fire wounds Ross Marine
It's a small world after all
Keeping in touch
IN THE TRISTATE
Police center moving forward
City seeks to replace attorneys
Students get a jump on college in UC program
Obituary: Andrew J. Schmidt, 92,
Tristate A.M. Report
McNUTT: Morgan's Raiders return
Faith Matters: Workshop way 2 faiths can relate
BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Miami U. photo project slammed
Mason chess whizzes keep it in family
Struble students, staff honor teacher's memory at marathon
Cincinnati State students get Wilmington leg up
Investigators say fire not a hate crime
Butler offers week of substance abuse events
Three men face charges in separate Internet sex cases
Man pleads guilty in case involving dozens of fires
Autoworker receives nearly four years for plot to bomb steel mill
Airport screener numbers evaluated
Say goodbye to low pressure, hello to higher rates
Wal-Mart to anchor center in Ft. Wright
Krey sworn in and now running for PVA
Nunn moves to declare Fletcher ineligible
Court: Suit against Drees can be tried
U.S. adviser, UK scholar B. Vincent Davis dies