The Associated Press
LOUISVILLE - A federal judge has ruled that Louisville-Jefferson County Metro Government's ordinance restricting the location and operation of strip clubs and adult novelty stores amounts to a prior restraint of free speech.
U.S. District Judge Charles R. Simpson III on Friday barred metro government from enforcing its adult-entertainment ordinance. Simpson indicated he might throw it out entirely because it is unconstitutional.
Simpson said the ordinance also fails to set a time limit for approving or denying a license application, potentially leaving applicants in a "legal limbo."
Bill O'Brien, head of County Attorney Irv Maze's civil division, said Simpson's ruling "greatly opens up where (adult businesses) can operate."
The injunction prohibits the metro government from restricting adult businesses from locating within 500 feet of residentially zoned land, churches, schools, parks or any other adult establishment.
Also blocked are requirements that adult businesses pay a $1,000 annual license fee, employees pay a $25 license fee and owners and operators disclose information about themselves and their business.
And performers won't have to stay at least 6 feet from patrons.
Mike Hatzell, attorney for two adult book and video stores that challenged the ordinance, was elated. Metro officials "can no longer use this bogus ordinance to prosecute" legitimate businesses, he said.
The metro government is considering an appeal.
"We don't want these (adult) businesses in residential areas," said Metro Council President Ron Weston, D-13th District.
Jefferson County attorneys said the government still has a variety of criminal statutes, alcoholic-beverage-control measures and building and health regulations they can use to rein in adult businesses.
TRISTATE REACTS TO WAR
He provides aid and comfort
French students postpone visit
D.C. trip canceled again for Evendale
Creating a wave of support
Events around the Tristate
Keeping in touch
IN THE TRISTATE
Family visits scene of fatal fire
Stress team helps folks cope after tragedy
Blackwell speaks out at 'Language of Race' forum
Tristate A.M. Report
SMITH AMOS: The real story
BRONSON: Brand new day
PULFER: Firefighter's death
HOWARD: Some Good News
BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Fight for baby puts focus on registries
Exhibit reveals visions of future
Obituary: Mary Kay Asher, 48, hospital supervisor
Bill seeks humane deaths at pounds
Voinovich bucks Bush on tax cut
Candidates hit track to mingle
Settlements reached in two church cases
Could elections have tarnished Kentucky's image?
Adult business ordinance barred
Ham biscuit tops at 2,200 pounds