Saturday, March 15, 2003

Residents sue to halt razing



By Dan Horn
The Cincinnati Enquirer

English Woods residents sued in federal court Friday to stop demolition of their low-income housing project.

The lawsuit accuses officials at the Cincinnati Metropolitan Housing Authority of deliberately reducing occupancy and maintenance at English Woods so they could justify closing the 700-unit complex.

The suit also claims racial discrimination because about 95 percent of residents there are African-American.

"We have nowhere else to go," said Marcia Battle, vice president of the English Woods Resident Community Council. "We think you should improve the lives of the people who live in this community instead of just moving people out."

In the lawsuit, the community council asks U.S. District Judge Sandra Beckwith to issue an injunction that would block CMHA's plans to close and then demolish English Woods.

The residents also want the judge to order CMHA to resume rentals and regular maintenance on all units.

"We think this is good, basic housing," said John Schrider, the community council's lawyer.

CMHA officials could not be reached for comment Friday, but they have argued for months that English Woods is obsolete and unsafe. They say repairs could cost as much as $130,000 per unit.

The residents, however, say CMHA has intentionally allowed conditions in English Woods to deteriorate so it could replace the complex with a new mixed-income neighborhood. They say CMHA's own estimates in 1999 found that renovation would cost only about $19,000 per unit.

CMHA officials have said they are considering a mixed-income replacement for English Woods but have no firm plans to build such a complex.

City officials and neighborhood leaders have opposed the closure.

CMHA's demolition plans will soon go to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development for approval. If granted, English Woods residents could be relocated before the end of the year.

E-mail dhorn@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Taft seeks end to tax deals with neighbors
Snow melts to pools of red
Tax change plan uses old data
Remark brings call for apology
'Vagina monologues' expands into censorship debate

IN THE TRISTATE
Amber Alerts available in Ky. and Ohio
Residents sue to halt razing
Councilman one of two arrested on Net sex charges
Two arrested in robbery spree
Blue Ash hones its planning
Grass-roots movement launched to improve Ryan Park
Obituary: Joseph Rosen
Dr. Noble Owen Fowler, cardiologist, researcher
Soldiers' pets need care
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
McNUTT: Neighborhoods
FAITH MATTERS: Kidney donation a lesson

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Tainted soil was rototilled
Tracks, dead deer hint cougar on prowl
Bullet hits Ross man at home
She reaches kids in her books

OHIO
Beef that made children ill likely produced here
Execution postponed after lawyers say man is retarded
New E-check proposal: Newer cars can skip test, fee applies
Midwife jailed over medicine use
Opposition to Ohio incinerator fades
Five-pound delivery surprises new mom
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Kenton Central won't die
Gaming advocates rethink strategy
2 bids for school property fall short
Ex-NKU Foundation chief now indicted
Bush OKs financial help for Kentucky storm victims
Mom charged with murder in 2001 shooting
Inmate's death investigated
St. Pius X adding on to keep up with growth
Trial set for Erlanger man found with teen
Missing N.Ky. teens found in California
Lt. Gov. candidate attacks opponent