Thursday, March 13, 2003

Council rejects police contract



By Gregory Korte
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Cincinnati City Council again rejected a contract for police supervisors Wednesday, sending the issue to binding arbitration.

The city and the Fraternal Order of Police are at odds over the five assistant chief positions contained in the bargaining unit. Issue 5, a charter amendment approved by voters in 2001, removed those positions from civil service and allowed the city manager to hire and fire assistant chiefs directly.

But a Louisville arbitrator found Tuesday that the city's charter conflicts with state collective-bargaining law, and recommended the city adopt the tentative agreement negotiated by the city manager and the police union in December.

City Council, by a 7-2 vote, rejected that recommendation. The issue now moves from fact-finding, which either party can reject, to binding arbitration.

Councilman Pat DeWine blamed City Manager Valerie Lemmie's administration.

"The people are sovereign, and the will of the people was blatantly disregarded in this contract," he said. "Certainly, the city was not well represented at the bargaining table, and we all bear responsibility for that."

Among city negotiators was Police Chief Tom Streicher, who vocally opposed Issue 5 in 2001. Lemmie has said the city could not force the FOP to negotiate a provision it was opposed to, no matter who was at the table.

DeWine said the city offered police supervisors a bigger pay raise if they agreed to the charter change, but the FOP refused.

Republican Chris Monzel, who joined Charterite JimTarbell in dissenting, said the city's futile attempts to dictate terms of the contract were sending the wrong message to officers.

"We need to fight crime instead of fighting our police force," he said.

Councilman John Cranley said he's for the charter. "I think what you're beginning to see is that despite the turmoil of the last couple of years, this council has a backbone," he said.

E-mail gkorte@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Covington Diocese must open its files
Troopers sparing speeders in Warren
Study: System fails accused youth in Ohio
County's juvenile justice 'alarming'

IN THE TRISTATE
Support our troops, says Fountain Square crowd
Class championing play
Contaminated ground beef recalled
Council rejects police contract
West End joins critics of housing policy
E-mail trips up fire chief
Krings' severance deal is reduced
Loveland to permit change in zoning during annexation
Traffic issues atop Green Twp. survey
Obesity big target in U.S. health effort
Obituary: Allen E. Paul, 84,
Ohio Moments

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
PULFER: Natural dilemma
HOWARD: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Bus funds not paid; riders angered
Mason schools tackling race after remarks cited
Monroe seeks to annex site along I-75
Retailer indicted on smut charges
Vandals cause $40,000 damage to small church
Orange barrels soon to appear on Deerfield Road
Oxford clamping down on parties
Parents in military get extra help
West Chester suing complex
Tentative site picked for recreation center

KENTUCKY
Airport may raise fees on parking lots
Burgeoning Burlington treats itself to makeover
2 doctors now face action in Ohio, too
NKU opens windows to history Saturday
Schools making up lost days by adding minutes
IRS names field director for center in Covington