Friday, March 7, 2003

Ten Commandments challenge awaits ruling



The Associated Press

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. - The challenge involving a deposed Ten Commandments display at the Rutherford County Courthouse has been delayed until a federal appeals court rules on a nearly identical case from Kentucky.

U.S. District Court Judge Robert Echols of Nashville granted a defense request to take no further action in the Tennessee lawsuit pending a 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruling expected later this year, said Erik Stanley, an attorney for the county.

Echols issued a preliminary injunction in June that ordered Rutherford County to remove the display. The American Civil Liberties Union of Tennessee, which filed the lawsuit, had asked Echols to make his order permanent.

But the Liberty Counsel, a Florida religious civil liberties group that is representing the county for free, successfully argued for the delay because the appellate decision will guide its defense, Stanley told the Daily News Journal.

The county commission posted the Ten Commandments in April with the Bill of Rights, the Mayflower Compact, the Declaration of Independence, the Magna Carta and the Preamble of the Tennessee Constitution.

Echols decided the posting was unconstitutional because the commission's intent was entirely religious. Commission votes made after the posting that declared a historical reason were a "sham," the judge said.

The Kentucky case involves appeals by Harlan, Pulaski and McCreary counties of a trial court decision that required they remove the Ten Commandments from public buildings.




TOP STORIES
Pull-tab lottery tied to terror
Robotic surgery comes to TriHealth
Test-driving the da Vinci device
Tarbell floats idea of tax on water taxi
Convict given 'vacation' from jail

IN THE TRISTATE
Grand jury hears Deters testimony in theft case
Fights, taunts led up to shooting
Bullying among 4 factors for youth violence, expert says
Churches target Cincinnati in campaign to help blacks
County report looks at trends, points to problems needing fix
Edward Dinerman, 94, longtime advertising exec
Catherine 'Kit' Nicholas oversaw labs at hospitals
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
BRONSON: Blame game
HOWARD: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Green Beer Day somewhat flat; fewer revelers
Shed giant sign, county tells Hustler
Deal struck for Metro routes
Clermont adopts clean water plan
Admirers help out a champ
Realtors protest Butler tax plan

OHIO
State's school districts told to brace for even deeper cuts
No clemency advised for man on Ohio death row
Panelists disagree on how to select Ohio's judiciary
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Industrial Road to gain girth
N.Ky. shelter to close for the season
Kentucky obituaries
Ky. trucker killed when 3 semis collide
Doctor accused of pushing painkillers
Ten Commandments challenge awaits ruling
Epling-inspired bill gets House OK
Attorney: Confessed killer's testimony wasn't perjury
KET names Oklahoma TV executive new CEO
Off the Beam, on your Mark
Martha Comer led Maysville paper