By Sharon Turco
The Cincinnati Enquirer
For months, a 13-year-old North Fairmount boy had been clashing with three teenagers who lived in his Beekman Street apartment building, according to testimony Thursday in Hamilton County Juvenile Court.
A handcuffed 13-year-old accused of shooting a 15-year-old to death is taken out of Hamilton County Juvenile Court after a hearing Thursday.
The Cincinnati Enquirer/TONY JONES
They had once been friends, but the boy told police that Michale and Jatawn Swan had been having sex with his sisters, which angered him. He said the Swans and their friend, Arick Hudson, taunted him, words turning to violence.
On Feb. 20, the boy told police, he'd had enough of the older boys' bullying. He said he borrowed a .380 semiautomatic handgun from an 18-year-old clerk at a nearby convenience store and, when the boys came near, he started firing.
Witnesses and police pieced together what happened that night during the Thursday hearing.
"They had arguments, they had been fighting. ... Michale and Jatawn threw (the sexual relationships) in his face, kind of pushed his button," Cincinnati Police Officer Keith Witherell testified. "He stated he had to release himself because he was frustrated."
Arick, 15, was shot to death. Michale, 14, who took a bullet in the neck; is paralyzed from the neck down. Jatawn, 15, was hit in the fleshy part of his shoulder and has recovered.
The 13-year-old, whom the Enquirer is not identifying because of his age, faces juvenile charges of murder with a firearm and two counts of felonious assault with a firearm. Juvenile Judge Sylvia Hendon determined Thursday the case can be presented to a grand jury.
Attorney Clyde Bennett, who represents the 13-year-old, does not dispute that the shooting happened. He says the boy did not mean to injure or kill anyone. He was reacting to the victims' antagonizing comments about his sisters and their sexual relationship, and their repeated attacks on him, Bennett said.
"(The boy) feels horrible," the attorney said. "The cross-examination of the police officer indicated the defendant felt threatened by these individuals when they appeared in his presence.
"He fired a weapon in an attempt to stop an attack," Bennett added.
The boy is among the youngest people ever charged with murder in Hamilton County. His case comes less than two years after an 8-year-old Northside girl was beaten to death by a 13-year-old male cousin and her 11-year-old brother. Both those boys were found guilty on juvenile murder counts.
Thursday's hearing in the North Fairmount case was to determine whether the 13-year-old can be designated a serious youthful offender, meaning, if convicted, he could serve part of his sentence in the adult prison system. The hearing was continued.
As the boy, his legs shackled, huddled close to his mother Thursday at the defense table, Witherell recalled Feb. 20, describing how the deadly afternoon unfolded.
Officers were called to Beekman Street at 4:30 p.m. where the boys had been fighting, Witherell said. The fight dispersed and the boys went their separate ways.
Two hours later the boys ended up together at MJ's Variety Store at Beekman and Dempsey streets, a convenience store where teens often hang out.
The 13-year-old boy was with a sister and a female cousin when the Swans and Hudson walked up, the officer said.
Earlier in the week, Michale and the boy had fought, and Michale wanted to finish the fight, Jatawn said in his testimony Thursday.
"What's up? Let's fight one-on-one," Jatawn recalled his brother saying. "It wasn't going to be no jumping."
Witherell said the 13-year-old told officers he became fearful when the three walked toward him. Words were exchanged, but the officer did not specifically say what was said.
The boy asked his 18-year-old clerk friend to give him the gun. He did, warning, "Don't do anything you'll regret," the boy told police.
The clerk went back to work.
"By that time the boys had passed him, but they came back," Witherell said. "That's when he fired."
He fired in between the boys, the bullets striking the victims as they scattered, the officer testified.
"He never said he tried to kill anybody," Witherell said.
The boy said he doesn't remember how many shots were fired.
"He pulled out a gun and just started shooting," Jatawn testified. "I was trying to get away... I heard three gunshots ... I was hit by a bullet."
Jatawn escaped into a friend's car, not knowing if his friends had been hurt.
At the gunshots, the store clerk returned and took the gun back. The boy stopped, hugged his sister and cousin, then ran home, according to police. His mother met him at the door.
"He said don't worry, hugged her and went upstairs," Witherell said.
911 calls poured into the Police Department and officers found the boy at home. Witherell described him as cooperative.
The clerk gave the gun to police and has not been charged in the case. Cincinnati police say they are still investigating.
Pull-tab lottery tied to terror
Robotic surgery comes to TriHealth
Test-driving the da Vinci device
Tarbell floats idea of tax on water taxi
Convict given 'vacation' from jail
IN THE TRISTATE
Grand jury hears Deters testimony in theft case
Fights, taunts led up to shooting
Bullying among 4 factors for youth violence, expert says
Churches target Cincinnati in campaign to help blacks
County report looks at trends, points to problems needing fix
Edward Dinerman, 94, longtime advertising exec
Catherine 'Kit' Nicholas oversaw labs at hospitals
Tristate A.M. Report
BRONSON: Blame game
HOWARD: Some Good News
BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Green Beer Day somewhat flat; fewer revelers
Shed giant sign, county tells Hustler
Deal struck for Metro routes
Clermont adopts clean water plan
Admirers help out a champ
Realtors protest Butler tax plan
State's school districts told to brace for even deeper cuts
No clemency advised for man on Ohio death row
Panelists disagree on how to select Ohio's judiciary
Industrial Road to gain girth
N.Ky. shelter to close for the season
Ky. trucker killed when 3 semis collide
Doctor accused of pushing painkillers
Ten Commandments challenge awaits ruling
Epling-inspired bill gets House OK
Attorney: Confessed killer's testimony wasn't perjury
KET names Oklahoma TV executive new CEO
Off the Beam, on your Mark
Martha Comer led Maysville paper