Saturday, March 1, 2003

Enhanced DUI penalty upheld



By Bruce Schreiner
The Associated Press

FRANKFORT - A law enhancing the penalty for drunken drivers with blood alcohol levels more than double the legal limit - even first offenders - is constitutional, the Kentucky Court of Appeals ruled Friday.

The court rejected a defendant's claim that the law's standard for an enhanced penalty - a 0.18 blood alcohol level - was arbitrary. He also said the law penalized drivers who submitted to blood alcohol tests and did not apply to drivers intoxicated on other substances.

Under Kentucky law, a motorist is presumed intoxicated at a 0.08 blood-alcohol level. The appeal was by Steve Whitehouse, who was charged in 1999 with first-offense drunken driving with a blood alcohol concentration over 0.18.

Whitehouse entered a conditional guilty plea and challenged the law's constitutionality. Whitehouse was sentenced to two days in jail and fined $200. He appealed to Marion County Circuit Court, which upheld the penalty enhancement.

Writing for the appeals court, Judge Wilfrid Schroder of Covington noted that the Kentucky Supreme Court earlier upheld the enhanced penalty for third-offense drunken drivers and declared that the 0.18 standard is not arbitrary.

Schroder also said the General Assembly "has the discretion to single out alcohol from other intoxicating substances for penalty enhancement purposes."

Judges Matthew Baker of Bowling Green and Daniel Guidugli of Newport joined in the ruling.

The court also upheld the dismissal of a suit against Paxton Media Group by a worker injured in a fall from a Paxton television tower in Ballard County. The appellant claimed the tower's ladder lacked a mandatory safety device.




TOP STORIES
English Woods tenants: Problems, but it's home
Paraplegic driver guilty of homicide
Tipster's account leads to arrest

IN THE TRISTATE
Kids' breakfasts go begging
Boycott panel answers questions
2nd chance for Loveland vote
Stewart decision could be soon
Students celebrate history
Cheviot juggles money to cover salt expenses
City employees dodge layoffs
Observation deck in works for canal tunnel
Obituary: Ralph Plagge
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
RADEL: An outside shot
GUTIERREZ: Fort Thomas crisis
McNUTT: Neighborhoods
FAITH MATTERS: AIDS focus of prayer

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Rep. Raga won't support impact fees
Butler, Clermont bus riders worried
Fairfield won't shoot coyotes
College, churches labor together
Hamilton track star becomes AD at Fairfield

OHIO
Diocese adopts abuse policy
Lawmakers trying to preserve conservation corps
Drunken driver, MADD member form alliance
Lower DUI limit sought
Tree-killing borer beetles moving into Ohio from Michigan
Author answers: What's in a name?
Ohio begins celebration today in original capital - Chillicothe
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Cities lobby to keep police funds
'Nothing personal,' senators tell Henry
New Cinergy substation came as surprise to Boone County
Schools may get to shorten year
Former officer accuses ex-chief of sex assault
Enhanced DUI penalty upheld
Former Ky. governor files for third divorce
Kentucky obituaries