Thursday, February 27, 2003

Mason wins appeal in land purchase dispute



By Erica Solvig
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Warren County neighbors Deerfield Township and Mason are still trying to resolve litigation that dates back to a 1999 land dispute.

On Monday, the 12th Ohio District Court of Appeals upheld a lower court's ruling that Deerfield Township must pay $45,604 in attorney fees and court costs. The bill was from a legal battle over a 6-acre parcel along Mason Road, where the city's water tower has since been built.

Deerfield sued Mason after the city purchased the land for $385,000. The township tried to use eminent domain to get the land, which trustees wanted for a park and fire station.

Under eminent domain, a government body has the right to take private property for public use, but it must pay fair market value.

A judge dismissed the suit in December 2000. The township appealed, but later withdrew it. The city also filed a motion to get attorney fees and court costs covered.

"The decision (Monday) from the court of appeals reinforced what had been previously decided," Mason City Manager Scot Lahrmer said. "This is just a protection of taxpayer money that had to be expended in order to defend a frivolous suit against the city."

Mason officials said they gave the township "every chance" to settle the case. The city also plans to pursue the costs of the appeal, which Mason Law Director Kenneth Schneider estimates at $20,000.

Deerfield Township officials have not decided whether to appeal. Trustees are likely to discuss it Friday.

E-mail esolvig@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Elderly victim was tortured, coroner says
Violence comes to North End
N.Ky. nurse one of first to get vaccine
Two city police officers fired

IN THE TRISTATE
City homicides outpacing 2002
Defendant says he wasn't driver
Swarm wants into school
Delta to test new security program
City to borrow $6.5M to upgrade recreation
CPS contracts with minority businesses growing
Norwood's budget $2M shy of last year
Obituary: Dr. Erin Talbot McNeill
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
RADEL: New ballpark pity parties
PULFER: Frank Abagnale Jr.
HOWARD: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Liberty Twp. changing its administrator
Students talk to overseas soldier
Ky. team to play, but in Ohio
Mason wins appeal in land purchase dispute
Twp. may grant $4M to developer
Eads-Stumpf benefit raises over $12,500
Agreement on Mason center in final stage
Complex open to public Saturday
Lebanon to extend sewer to subdivision
Contract signed for skate rink to move
Grant for two schools teaches about disabilities

OHIO
This town is party central
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Former jail worker accepts settlement
Flooding a close call, but Tristate escapes
E-mail inaccurately claims tax vote delay
Activist knows cold and fear of living on the riverbank
Bill targets corrupt Ky. officials