Saturday, February 22, 2003

No sprinklers 'footprint' in club disasters



By Cindy Schroeder
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Twenty-six years later, the statistics from the Tristate's deadliest blaze still stagger the imagination: 165 killed and 164 injured in the May 28, 1977, fire at the Beverly Hills Supper Club.

It was a tragedy that brought then-Gov. Julian Carroll to his knees at the scene and which resonates throughout the Tristate. Time is marked "before Beverly Hills" and "after Beverly Hills" in Northern Kentucky.

As news of the Rhode Island fire unfolded, Cincinnati attorney Stan Chesley recalled the Beverly Hills disaster and other major fires.

"It's dj vu," the attorney who led the class-action suit for Beverly Hills victims said. "Here we have an unsprinkled building which is a place of public access, particularly for young people. It's brain dead to suggest that a building should have pyrotechnics."

The Rhode Island tragedy was eerily similar to the Beverly Hills blaze, the MGM Grand Hotel fire in Las Vegas in 1980 and the San Juan Dupont Plaza Hotel blaze Dec. 31, 1986. Each claimed scores of lives.

"They all have the same footprint," Chesley said. "We have not lost lives in any sprinkled building in the last 40 to 50 years. The key to eliminating the spread of fire and flames and smoke is early detection and early (extinguishment) which can only be accomplished by sprinklers."

Chesley pioneered class-action cases in such disasters when he not only sued the Richard Schilling family that owned Beverly Hills, he also sued industries and services. The 1,200 defendants included insurance companies; the companies that made the club's faulty aluminum wiring; and the manufacturers of the furnishings, carpeting, and other materials that gave off the poisonous gases when they burned.

The Kentucky state fire code was overhauled and national fire safety experts cite the Beverly Hills fire as a turning point for public fire safety.




TOP STORIES
Club scene is busy, but so are local inspectors
No sprinklers 'footprint' in club disasters
It shouldn't have happened again, say veterans of 1977 tragedy
Daughter follows military path
A show, plus a festival

IN THE TRISTATE
Man indicted in stolen funds case
Family, friends mourn teenager
Accused robber tried to hire hit man on witness, police say
Pupils find ways to use new tablet computers
Norwood, builders making pact
Golden Corral adding Westwood restaurant
Obituary: The Rev. Edward Stolze
Ohio Moments
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
RADEL: Can you hear me yet?
GUTIERREZ: Mansion for sale
FAITH MATTERS: 'Women of the South' on display
McNUTT: Neighborhoods

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Mold in apartments nearly cleaned up
Composer's visit warms singers
Hunting preserve maintains permit
Group opposing new development

KENTUCKY
Ky. Senate leader: Slots are long shot
Ky. bill intended to protect buyers
Bidder wants 2nd chance
Senate bill would make dog, cat torture felony
Four arrested in armed holdup of video store
Blasted factory future uncertain
Kentucky obituaries