Saturday, February 15, 2003

Sparta, residents lose court battle with Speedway


Racetrack comes up victorious in separate lawsuits

By Patrick Crowley
The Cincinnati Enquirer

SPARTA - The Kentucky Speedway scored two major legal victories Friday in what has been a running legal dispute with the city of Sparta and a group of residents.

The Kentucky Court of Appeals affirmed two lower-court rulings made in favor of the speedway by Gallatin County Circuit Court Judge Jay Bamberger, who also oversees Boone Circuit Court.

The cases dealt with how the racetrack was funded, and a thwarted attempt by the tiny city, which has a population of only 133, to annex the track.

A group of 13 Gallatin County residents had challenged the validity of $35 million in industrial-revenue bonds issued by the Gallatin County Fiscal Court used to help finance the $152 million speedway.

The residents claimed the county made errors when it issued the bonds and published a notice of the bond issue in the Gallatin County News.

Bond issues must be advertised and announced in local newspapers under state law.

But in a unanimous opinion written by Court of Appeals Justice R.W. Dyche, the court found nothing improper in the way bonds were advertised and issued.

Lawyer Richard Meyer, who represented the speedway, said the court's ruling did not surprise him.

"We've known from the outset that the bond financing was done according to law," Meyer said Friday. "And this decision validates our belief."

In the other case, Sparta had attempted to annex the speedway, which covers an area nearly four times as large as the city.

Dyche, the author of a second unanimous ruling, said the city did not follow the proper procedures set by the state's annexation laws.

"The city failed to comply, strictly or otherwise, with the applicable statutes," Dyche said.

Dyche went on to say the city showed "egregious disregard for the orderly statutory process."

"That may well be the understatement of the century," lawyer Mark Guilfoyle, also a speedway attorney, said of Dyche's comments.

Lawyers for the residents and the city could not reached to comment.

E-mail pcrowley@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Disabled man missing after Delhi Twp. blaze
Local peace groups spreading wings
Broker ordered to repay, 'suffer'

IN THE TRISTATE
CMHA funds rerouted to city water
Ridge coming to Hamilton Co.
Tip leads to teen with gun
Repeat snow, ice predicted
Obituary: Seton mourns Sister Mary Consolata
Obituary: Betty Warren helped children
Officer loses baton in fight
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
RADEL: 'Duct and cover'
GUTIERREZ: Heading to 100
FAITH MATTERS: Group visiting 'family'
McNUTT: Neighborhoods

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Drug raid nets four juveniles
Sycamore tired of teacher fight
Military families needn't be alone
Butler Co. starts prescription drug help
Lebanon gets $400,000 to help students improve fitness
Strip center proposed at I-74 and Harrison

OHIO
Police are immune, appeals court rules
Strickland not amused by TV's new 'Hillbillies'

KENTUCKY
Kenton restores its town meetings
Covington seeks more input on ordinance
Marrying Man: 'Tell 'em I'm back'
Louisville man says 'not guilty' in Connecticut couple's slayings
State gets $8 million for new drug initiative
Congress approves millions for N. Ky.
Appeals court won't enter squabble over education
Boy charged in bomb scare
Sparta, residents lose court battle with Speedway
Barrows apologizes to House, keeps job
New center to research 'smart heart' technology