Thursday, February 13, 2003

House panel approves bill to prohibit cloning



By Bruce Schreiner
The Associated Press

FRANKFORT - A bill aimed at outlawing human cloning while allowing university scientists to create human cells for medical research won approval from a House committee Wednesday.

The measure, which cleared the Judiciary Committee on a 12-5 vote, would outlaw cloning meant to create another human. Violators would be guilty of a felony punishable by 10 to 20 years in prison.

The bill would still allow a medical procedure known as somatic cell nuclear transplantation, in which researchers transfer the nucleus between cells to cultivate human tissue. Researchers would have to register with the state at least 30 days before doing such work.

Rep. Larry Clark of Louisville said his bill was modeled after legislation introduced in the U.S. Senate by two Republican senators. Clark said his bill would achieve a balance by banning reproductive cloning while giving researchers the leeway to continue medical research.

"This legislation is about curing, it's not about cloning," said Clark, the second-ranking Democrat in the House.

The measure sparked debate between abortion opponents - who said the bill didn't go far enough - and officials from the University of Kentucky and University of Louisville, who said stem-cell research could lead to breakthroughs in treating a series of incurable diseases.

The issue hits close to home because a researcher in Lexington, Panayiotis Michael Zavos, is part of a project to clone human embryos for infertile women. Zavos has said the cloning work is being done outside the United States. Zavos' name did not come up during the committee hearing.

In opposing the bill, abortion opponents saw no distinction between reproductive cloning and so-called "therapeutic" cloning.

Such medical research results in new human life, said the Rev. Thomas Smith, representing the Catholic Conference of Kentucky.

"The harvesting of stem cells produced in this fashion requires the destruction of new, existing embryonic human life, and as such is immoral to the ultimate degree," Smith said in a statement.

Michael Janocik, assistant director of Kentucky Right to Life Association, said the bill would provide a "firm legal foundation for a new industry based on the mass creation of cloned human embryos to be killed for research and commercial applications."

Rep. Charles Geveden, D-Wickliffe, said he had no moral or legal misgivings in supporting the bill. He said the bill promoted life by letting scientists pursue research that could lead to cures for diseases.

"I think this is pro-life because it can prolong life, it can improve the quality of life and it can save lives," Geveden said.

Del Collins, UK's associate vice president for research, said the stem-cell research is viewed by many medical experts as "the next great breakthrough in medical care."

Every day, people die while awaiting organ transplants, Collins said. He said stem-cell technology may someday be used to repair damaged organs. At UK, researching are pinning hopes on stem-cell research that could lead to a breakthrough to prevent Alzheimer's disease, he said.

Collins was critical of a competing anti-cloning bill that he said would prohibit such research. That bill has been referred to the House Judiciary Committee but was not called up Wednesday.




TOP STORIES
Lawsuit says Ky. diocese covered up for priests
Ky. teachers rally to protect funding
Developer planning Mason mall site
Soldiers heading to war keep genes on active duty

IN THE TRISTATE
Tristate doesn't seem too terrified
Board votes to change administrator's contract
Saturday's a school day
Recreation tiff prompts call for new ethics rule
Suit against Enquirer dismissed
Suit over superintendent selection dismissed
Obituary: Albert Brooks
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
RADEL: Morgan trumps Marge
PULFER: Horse auction
HOWARD: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
St. Thomas mourns loss of student
I-75/Fox interchange priorities are listed
Teens get tougher sentence
Disease steals breath, dreams
Finke moves to Lakota
Lebanon leaders get pay raise
Milford asks voters for school levy again in May
Trustees postpone traffic study of Hamilton-Mason
Ah, the palms of Miami, swaying in Ohio's winter wind
Trustees divided over Liberty Twp. takeover
Hummer Memorial Park wins award from state

OHIO
House defies Taft on budget
House approves taxes-free budget fix
Body-double murder plot gets Ohio woman 20 years
Concealed weapons charge thrown out
Bills to try again for lower DUI limit
No last words as killer executed
State librarian saved Lincoln's life
In upscale suburb, parents of black students less involved

KENTUCKY
Buyer protection posed
Forum ponders how to end homelessness
Patton case hits grand jury
Remark on radio jeopardizes grant
House panel weighs medical malpractice fix
Priest's journal suggests church knew of abuse
Lucas on anti-terror panel
House panel approves bill to prohibit cloning