Monday, February 3, 2003

Safety, money, expertise on line

Numerous reports question NASA's support abilities

By Pete Yost
The Associated Press

WASHINGTON - Shortages of key experts, tight budgets and mounting safety concerns all plagued the nation's space program in recent years, according to a trail of reports by congressional auditors, outside panels and NASA retirees.

How much of a forewarning they were to Saturday's space shuttle Columbia tragedy may be determined in the next several weeks.

NASA critics in and outside the government, and investigators of the accident are sure to comb the reports for anything that might explain the disintegration of the spacecraft nearly 40 miles above Texas.

As President Bush took office, the investigative arm of Congress found in 2001 that NASA's shuttle work force over the years had declined significantly to the point of reducing the agency's ability to safely support the program.

Many key areas were not sufficiently staffed by qualified workers and the remaining work force showed signs of overwork and fatigue, the General Accounting Office stated. There were other warnings, including a report to Congress last April on the shuttle program by a federally mandated safety panel of outside experts that expressed "the strongest safety concern" in 15 years.

"We just received a GAO report, I think last week, that looked at NASA's oversight of some of their private contractors and basically said it was inadequate," Sen. John Breaux, D-La., said Sunday on CNN.

Members of Congress made clear Sunday that safety and the NASA budget will come under intense scrutiny on Capitol Hill this year, beginning today when the White House sends lawmakers details of Bush's priorities for the agency next year.

"Inevitably, there will be a discussion out of this about how much NASA should be funded, should there be another orbiter built, and in fact, has it been so poorly funded in recent years that maybe, just maybe, it wasn't as safe as it should be?" said Sen. Bill Nelson, D-Fla., a former astronaut who flew aboard Columbia.

The House Science Committee will take the lead in Congress' investigation of the tragedy, focusing on how much money has been devoted to the safety of the shuttle and other space programs and whether the disaster could have been prevented with more resources.

Last August, a retired NASA engineer, Don A. Nelson, wrote Bush about what he said was inadequate safety of the shuttle but was rebuffed by the White House's science adviser.

"Your intervention is required to prevent another catastrophic space shuttle accident," said Nelson, who is no relation to the senator. He suggested that shuttle crews be limited to four people, saying that "if this ... is ignored we can watch in horror and shame as the astronauts face certain death."

Bush science adviser John Marburger Sunday defended the way the administration dealt with Nelson's concerns and said that even in the wake of Sunday's accident, he would still make the same decisions. Nelson advocated an escape module for the shuttle crews, a proposal that would require extensive redesign efforts, NASA official Bill Readdy wrote in 1999.

"When we looked at the way NASA was responding to those issues we decided it was not justified," said Marburger.

White House spokesman Ari Fleischer said "clearly in this case, an escape pod would not have saved the lives of the astronauts given that they were 200,000 feet above Earth and flying at 12,000 mph, they would not have been able to survive."

While many of the warnings in years past about shuttle safety were blunt, they were often tempered with qualified praise for NASA.

In last April's report to Congress, the Aerospace Safety Advisory Panel noted "safety has not yet been compromised. NASA and its contractors maintain excellent safety practices and processes as well as a world-class level of safety consciousness."

(Complete Columbia coverage at

Flight and Ohio closely bound
Armstrong: Don't jump to conclusions
Tragedy will be topic in schools today
Tristaters pray for shuttle crew
Wright-Pat general to aid investigation

Was shuttle rescue possible?
Damaged heat tiles suspected
Manufacturer defends fuel tank
Why tile shuttle in first place?
Astronauts' remains should be indentifiable
Recovery teams scour schoolyards, woods
List of what's been recovered
Grieving Americans pay tribute
America absorbs another tragedy, tries to move on
Space station crew grieving but proud
Retired admiral to lead probe
Israeli astronaut's family arrives
Safety, money, expertise on line