Sunday, February 2, 2003

Families' pride turns to anguish

The Associated Press

It was to be a day of glory for seven families the world over.

In Israel, a brother had gathered to toast his brave sibling. In Wisconsin, another rose before sunup to see his sister fulfill a lifelong dream.

And at a majestic waterfront launch site in Florida, families of divergent backgrounds and cultures had come together to celebrate an event that bridged the differences: welcoming their loved ones home from space.

In one gut-wrenching moment, their common pride became shared grief as they struggled to understand the incomprehensible.

"I have no son," 79-year-old Eliezer Wolferman, the father of Columbia astronaut Ilan Ramon, told reporters in Jerusalem.

Just hours earlier, Wolferman beamed as he gave a live television interview shortly before the shuttle was due to land. He reminisced about the last time he spoke to his son, by video conference from Johnson Space Center in Houston.

"Our family saw him, and the children asked their dad to do somersaults in the air," he said.

Wolferman's son, Israel's first astronaut, was an icon not just to a family but to an entire nation. His father was proud, and it showed.

Then, a news flash. And the interviewer cut him off.

Soon, as word spread around the world that Columbia had disintegrated over Texas, Wolferman was back in front of the cameras, struggling with a tragedy he couldn't fathom.

"I think of everything from the day he was born until now," he said. "I have no son. It is very sad, and I don't know what else to say."

Ramon's brother, Gadi, had invited friends to the restaurant he owns to toast the landing. "Even in our wildest imaginations it didn't occur to us that something could happen," said Gadi, who had been afraid of flying. His brother always assured him driving was far more dangerous.

The astronaut's wife and four children were among the crew families that had gathered at Cape Canaveral for the landing.

After NASA lost contact with the shuttle Saturday, relatives were ushered to crew quarters where NASA officials delivered the somber news and President Bush called to offer condolences.

The families were being kept in seclusion and were expected later to fly to Houston, the astronauts' homebase during training.

Elsewhere across the nation, relatives struggled with shock and misery even as they sought to celebrate the astronauts' lives and the passion that drove them in spite of the dangers.

"It had been an absolutely flawless flight," crew member Laurel Clark's brother, Daniel Salton, said by phone from Milwaukee. He had risen at 5 a.m. to monitor Columbia's return. "To have this happen with 15 minutes to go until it was over was just unbelievable."

Only a day earlier, he had received an e-mail from his sister about how much she was enjoying her first flight aboard the space shuttle.

"I'm just so glad she got to get up to space and got to see it because that had been a dream for a long time," Salton said. "She saw the path to be an astronaut was open - she went at it full throttle all the way."

For Clark's aunt and uncle, Betty and Doug Haviland of Ames, Iowa, this tragedy brought back memories of another. Their son, Timothy, died in the World Trade Center collapse Sept. 11, 2001.

"You sort of had the sickening feeling that here we go again," 76-year-old Doug Haviland said.

Betty Haviland said her niece was "very proud to be representing her country."

"She had done something in a world usually reserved for men and she was pleased at the opportunity," she added.

Others voiced their support for the continuation of the space program that had cost them their loved ones.

"We want the space mission to go on," Audrey McCool, mother of pilot William C. McCool, said outside her Las Vegas home. Saying she was "obviously very distressed," she was preparing to head Sunday to Houston to join McCool's father in Houston.

"We don't want those people to have died in vain."

The University of Nevada, Las Vegas professor said she spoke with her son the day before the shuttle was launched. She declined to say what they talked about.

"The worst is when you have to look at his picture on the television," she said. "It was such a perfect mission. It was so perfect. It has been traumatizing."

(Complete Columbia coverage at

Tristaters shocked, seek answers
Terrace Park man loses friend on Columbia
Tristate Jews stunned by Israeli's death
India natives offer special prayers
KIESEWETTER: Another tragedy unfolds on TV
PULFER: Flight: a routine miracle
Enquirer seeking local connections
Disaster evokes Challenger image at Wright-Pat
School superintendent's hometown in debris path
Local woman witnessed 'perfect' launch
Ohio astronaut: `Oh, my God'
List of Ohio astronauts
Space program must go on, scientists say
DeWine: NASA funding will be rexamined
Reading firm makes shuttle fuel tanks

Archived video & special coverage from WCPO

Did NASA underestimate left-wing damage?
Body parts reportedly found
Columbia, crew of 7 lost
Families' pride turns to anguish
Texans saw trails in sky, heard booms
Final words: Astronauts gave no warning of disaster
Americans gasp, cry at news
Americans have taken space flights for granted
Bush consoles shuttle families, country
Text of Bush's remarks
Terrorism ruled out
Crew biographies: First Israeli aboard
Independent board to investigate
Landings were early safety concern
Challenger explosion recalled
Painful memories for teacher's hometown
Deadly accidents in space exploration
Former astronauts search for explanation
Space station crew won't be stranded
Timeline of Columbia flight
Columbia was NASA's oldest shuttle
Key dates in space program
New NASA administrator faces big task