Tuesday, January 14, 2003

Judge orders halt on construction



By Dan Horn
The Cincinnati Enquirer

A federal judge halted construction of a concrete distribution center in Sayler Park on Monday and accused authorities of ignoring her previous order to revoke permits for the project.

Clearly angry that construction was still going on, U.S. District Judge Susan Dlott said the concrete company, Lone Star Industries, had used "sleight of hand" to circumvent her previous orders.

She also blasted the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which granted Lone Star its permit to build, for failing to revoke the permit as she had ordered on Dec. 30.

"When federal judges order a defendant to do something, they are supposed to do it," Judge Dlott told lawyers for the Corps. "I'm mystified as to how a government agency can totally disregard an order of a federal court."

The judge's order Monday means Lone Star must immediately stop work on the project, which was to include concrete storage silos, several buildings and loading docks for river barges.

Sayler Park residents sued the Corps last year to stop construction, claiming the Corps violated its own rules for granting permits as well as the National Historic Preservation Act.

The residents say the distribution center is not appropriate for a residential area and would reduce the value of hundreds of historic homes in Sayler Park. They contend the Army Corps ignored concerns about the impact on historic sites when it gave Lone Star a permit to build along the Ohio River.

Judge Dlott agreed the permitting process was flawed and ordered the Corps on Dec. 30 to revoke its permit. In court Monday, lawyers for the Corps and the company suggested the judge may have overstepped her bounds, and that it would have been more proper for her to suspend the permit rather than revoke it.

They also argued that the Army Corps' permit only applies to the portion of the center in the river, such as the barge docks, and not to the land-based construction. Therefore, they said, the company continued building on land.

The residents' lawyer, Rhonda Frey, said the company was simply trying to circumvent a clear court order. The judge agreed and ordered an immediate halt to construction.

E-mail dhorn@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Budget crisis darkens tone of Taft's inauguration
Gov. Taft's Inaugural Address
Bradley step-up called a signal
Deters, Blackwell careers advance
Plans to shore up downtown on shoestring
Fairfield gets tough on massage parlors

IN THE TRISTATE
Police launch manhunt
Heimlich's first day: Cut losses
Judge hears criminal housing cases
Kids still aren't safe enough
Mayor says criminals will continue to feel heat
Ex-worker indicted; refused to return pay
Obituary: Glenmary Brother George Sauer
Cheviot, water utility plan road project
Judge orders halt on construction
Ohio Moments
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
PULFER: Geno the Clown
RADEL: Queen City Pride
HOWARD: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Housing unit awaits result of HUD scan
State board considers contract for Oak Tree
Take a look at plans for Deerfield parks
Woman alerts residents of blaze

KENTUCKY
Defense pulls out of Craven case
Hundreds expected to explore Carter Caves in annual event
Dems raise money in N.Ky.
Lawyers: Disregard statement to police
Patton's aide has parting shots
Covington's new leaders get organized
'Investment' scheme brings arrest