Tuesday, January 7, 2003

3 suing to stay can - for now


Estonians helped in criminal case

By Dan Horn
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Three Estonian women will be allowed to remain in Greater Cincinnati while they sue federal authorities for trying to deport them after they helped in a criminal investigation.

The women claim they helped the U.S. government prosecute their former boss after officers with the Immigration and Naturalization Service promised that their cooperation might be rewarded with U.S. citizenship.

But after their boss went to jail, the women received letters telling them to "voluntarily" leave the country. INS officials have said they promised the women nothing.

A federal judge in Covington threw out the Estonians' lawsuit in November, but he agreed last week to allow the women to remain in the United States until they have a chance to appeal his decision.

In his decision, U.S. District Judge David Bunning said he doubted the women would succeed in their appeal, but said the case raises important questions about immigration law.

"The court does recognize that there are serious issues which will be addressed on appeal," he wrote.

The women - Elvi Parmo, Susi Ene and Mare Kutt - have 60 days to appeal to the 6th U.S. Circuit Court in Cincinnati.

"This means we don't have to worry about going before an immigration judge while we appeal," said the women's lawyer, Candace Crouse.

The three Estonians came to the United States in the late 1990s for temporary jobs arranged by a company in their homeland. But when they arrived, they say, they were housed in a crowded apartment and forced to work as maids seven days a week, 12 hours a day.

They later agreed to tell federal authorities about their boss, Alexandre Grunichev, a Russian who was eventually sentenced to prison.

E-mail dhorn@enquirer.com




TOP LOCAL STORIES
Girl, 17, killed while holding child
Lottery sales up, but profit misses goal
Boyles gets 13 years in ex-girlfriend's death
Buckeyes gear flies out of stores
Troops ship out by the thousands

ENQUIRER COLUMNS
PULFER: Helping kids early and often
RADEL: Second job was what he wanted

CINCINNATI-HAMILTON COUNTY
Mt. Healthy stops school bus service
Mom, daughter killed in crash
School board elects Warner president
New police oversight agency meets
Another local boy joins Vienna choir
Donation to pay for flags on firetrucks
Firefighters, police aid McDonald House

AROUND THE TRISTATE
3 suing to stay can - for now
Class-action suit sought on Oxycontin
Obituary: Ruth Shaffer, 92, was organist
Obituary: Alfred Wilhelm, Diamond executive
Good News: Travel show partnering in coat drive
Congrats

BUTLER COUNTY
Perjury an issue in Butler courts
Deadly road gets rumble strips
Boil-water warning wasn't heard
Policeman hurt while questioning motorist
Fairfield laboratories focus on heart disease

WARREN COUNTY
Attempted murder added to charges
Rapist found slain in cell

OHIO
Ohio Moments: Midwest got a taste of Antarctica's weather
Blackwell: GOP should boost black staffing
Village ponders ads on cruisers

KENTUCKY
Democratic strategy session moved
Another local auto business burgled
Patton outlines tax-hike targets
Voters get voice at town meeting
$10M grant to help Kentucky's jobless
Jackson to run for Ky. governor
Around the Commonwealth