Thursday, December 26, 2002

Law requiring warnings to credit card users scrapped

By Jim Wasserman
The Associated Press

SACRAMENTO, Calif. - California's attempt to warn credit card customers about possible added costs and high debt burdens has ended in failure after a judge threw out the law, fearing it meddled in the business of banks.

State authorities called Monday's ruling a setback for consumers, especially college students and middle-income Californians who typically make minimum payments and contend with years of debt.

The law had required credit card firms to tell customers who make the lowest possible payment for six straight months how long it would take at that rate to pay off their debt. The warnings would have appeared on customers' monthly statements.

Advocates originally hailed the bill, sponsored by the New York-based Consumers Union and signed by Gov. Gray Davis on Oct. 10, 2001, as a national legislative victory.

But attorney Howard N. Cayne, who represents a consortium of major U.S. banks, praised the permanent injunction against the law issued Monday by U.S. District Judge Frank C. Damrell. Damrell, saying bank regulation is largely a federal arena, ruled that states cannot add costly new rules.

Five major credit card companies, including Citibank, Chase Manhattan, MBNA America Bank, First USA and Household Bank, argued the warnings would add millions of dollars in new costs and drive customers' minimum payments higher.

"California was attempting to exercise authority that Congress has granted exclusively to the federal regulatory agencies," Cayne said Tuesday.

A spokeswoman for California Attorney General Bill Lockyers said officials were reviewing the ruling for a possible appeal.


On the Net:

Read the original bill, AB865, at

College ready to sell concept
Implosion means lights out for Cinergy Field signs
West Virginia ticket has winning Powerball numbers
Shooter in 63rd homicide sought
Two men shot on Christmas night
Homicides match last year's 63
Teens' deaths a blow to schools
Volunteers spread cheer for holidays
U.S. soldiers celebrate Christmas with football, turkey
Celebrex not as protective against ulcers as was thought
Small cities use arts to boost economies
Humor causes Comair to cancel flight to CVG
Now broke, gambler sues Ind. casino
Organ off for $250K tuneup
Nor'easter delivers two ft. of snow to N.Y.
Cincinnati tax plan to cost county
Ohio congressional delegation sees much work ahead in 2003
3 arrested in slaying of 5 near Detroit
Nursing home resident wants to smoke indoors
Fourth-graders learn via interactive television
Howard: Some good news
Historical Society markers to honor Wilberforce, CSU
Tristate A.M. Report

Past meets future in creating image
Tristate Summary
North Carolina banks take new steps for protection
They're Bobs-bob-bobbin' along
Law requiring warnings to credit card users scrapped
Troubled airlines present additional challenge for FAA
As Linux advances, Microsoft alters message to lure customers
Smoker accepts $28 million in LA tobacco suit
Asian stocks offer little holiday cheer

Where 'close' counts
Get to it
Author turns to kids' books
Knip's eye view
Lawyer turned to guilty pleasure - comedy
It's still Christmas in 'July'
New stamp will depict Year of Ram
Top 10 lists
Group shapes TV's sexuality