Friday, December 13, 2002

Schools case


No license to drive education

map

My car is adequate. But I have noticed that some guys drive Cadillacs. That's unconstitutional.

If that sounds idiotic, it made perfect sense to the lame-duck liberal majority of the Ohio Supreme Court. Substitute schools for cars, and that's their warped logic: Some schools have leather seats, CD players and more cupholders and that's unconstitutional, they ruled in 1997. Every student is entitled to a Lexus classroom.

Never mind that the state constitution only requires "thorough and efficient'' schools. It says nothing about replacing Chevys with BMWs to make every school equal.

Cupholders standard

Never mind that a 1991 lawsuit failed to consider all the school improvements paid for by state taxpayers and local voters since then. Even basic Ford schools now have standard CD players and cupholders.

Ohio has increased funding 81 percent in 10 years. But Justice Paul Pfeifer called that "nibbling around the edges.'' Sure. Like the shark nibbled on swimmers in Jaws.

But never mind. They didn't want to be confused by the facts. And now that the liberal activists will soon lose control to a conservative majority elected on Nov. 6, they did what sore losers often do. They dismissed it all in a flurry of huffy name-calling, with logic as tangled as last year's Christmas lights.

The Wednesday ruling in two words: Never mind.

From Justice Pfeifer's majority opinion: "We do not regret that (earlier) decision, because it reflected a genuine effort by the majority to reach a solution to a troubling constitutional issue. However, upon being asked to reconsider that decision, we have changed our collective mind.''

Translation: We were out of our collective mind. But we will never admit it.

He wrote: "We realize that the General Assembly cannot spend money it does not have. Nevertheless, we reiterate that the constitutional mandate must be met.''

Translation: Ohio is broke. So raise taxes, but don't blame us if it wrecks the state economy.

10-year-old lemon

Justice Alice Robie Resnick called Chief Justice Thomas Moyer "imperceptive'' and "disingenuous.'' She said there was no point in repeating her rants against conservatives - but did so anyway.

Translation: We lost, but we refuse to lose gracefully.

Chief Justice Moyer wrote in his dissent: "Unfortunately, the majority today issues an opinion that ignores as many questions as it decides.''

Translation: After 10 years of litigation, embarrassing mistakes and ridiculous rulings, the activists achieved nothing but a colossal waste of Ohio's time and money in an attempt to destroy local control and let teacher unions reach into taxpayer pockets without school levy accountability.

Justice Deborah Cook, who is leaving to become a federal judge, gets the last word: "For the reasons I have expressed throughout this court's consideration of this cause, the court should dismiss this case.''

Translation: I was right when I said the court had no license to drive education. Adios. I'm outta here.

E-mail pbronson@enquirer.com or call 768-8301.




TOP STORIES
Owners circle the wagons to protect their equine friends
Reading scores up slightly
Lawmakers stay course on school fund setup
Finan: Taft may have to cut increases for schools

IN THE TRISTATE
City housing development fund supported
Obituary: Clifford Whigham, gym owner
City's planning director resigning amid breakup
Police narrowly OK 2-year contract
On sale: Chance to blow up stadium
Blue Ash planning documents available for public inspection
English Woods demolition on
Health officials prepare for smallpox vaccinations
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
BRONSON: Schools case
SMITH-AMOS: From the heart
HOWARD: Some Good News
WELLS: Trent Lott

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Cox Road finally loses hated array of barrels
We want to talk to you, Fairfield
Grant deal aids Mercantile repairs

OHIO
Slain priest returns in coffin to church he served
Dayton urged to keep sirens
Passing car badly hurts trooper at crash site

KENTUCKY
NKU, others brace for cutback
Fuel-oil tanker collapses bridge
Henrys expecting 2nd child
Animal case cost Kenton $30K
N.Ky. to hire coordinator in case of biological attack
Community protests adult book stores
Conner's nursing home just about out of money; could close soon
No drugs found in home of man killed in cuffs
Former Lexington bishop moving to new Ky. location