Cincinnati.Com
NKY.COM  |  ENQUIRER  |  CIN WEEKLY  |  Classifieds  |  Cars  |  Homes  |  Jobs  |  Help
Currently:
18°F
Mostly Cloudy
Weather | Traffic
The Enquirer
HOME
NEWS
ENTERTAINMENT
SPORTS
REDS
BENGALS
LOCAL GUIDE
MULTIMEDIA
ARCHIVES
SEARCH
 
 TODAY'S ENQUIRER 
 Front Page 
-- Local News 
 Sports 
 Business 
 Editorials 
 Tempo 
 Home Style 
 Travel 
 Health 
 Technology 
 Weather 
 Back Issues 
 Search 
 Subscribe 

 SPORTS 
 Bearcats 
 Bengals 
 High School 
 Reds 
 Xavier 

 VIEWPOINTS 
 Jim Borgman 
 Columnists 
 Readers' views 

 ENTERTAINMENT 
 Movies 
 Dining 
 Horoscopes 
 Lottery Results 
 Local Events 
 Video Games 

 CINCINNATI.COM 
 Giveaways 
 Maps/Directions 
 Send an E-Postcard 
 Coupons 
 Visitor's Guide 

 CLASSIFIEDS 
 Jobs 
 Cars 
 Homes 
 Obituaries 
 General 
 Place an ad 

 HELP 
 Feedback 
 Subscribe 
 Search 
 Newsroom Directory 




 
Wednesday, May 15, 2002

Pilot license suspended in sinking of towboat


Master reportedly knew vessel was taking on water

By Tom O'Neill, toneill@enquirer.com
The Cincinnati Enquirer

        Towboat master Richard Roberts reported water leaks to his employer, a U.S. Coast Guard spokesman said Tuesday, but was told to take the tow on its Ohio River assignment hours before it sank near Anderson Ferry on Monday.

[photo] The towboat Robert M sinks sinks into the Ohio River near the Anderson ferry Monday as another tow races in to rescue the crew of the stricken vessel.
(Photo provided by Don Phelps)
| ZOOM |
        On Tuesday, the Coast Guard suspended Mr. Roberts' license for 30 days and said the owner of the tow, George McGinnis Inc. of Sayler Park, faces serious questions about what it was told — and how it responded.

        The 60-foot Robert M. sank in the Ohio just before 5 p.m Monday about 1,000 feet downriver from Anderson Ferry. Two people on the vessel — Mr. Roberts and a deckhand — were pulled from the water by the crew of another towboat.

        Lt. Cmdr. Robert Bowen said Mr. Roberts of Cincinnati has no record of Coast Guard violations in his 25-year career. He called Mr. Roberts “an excellent mariner” who possibly saved lives when he steered the tow to within 300 feet of the Kentucky riverbank — out of the commercial navigation lane.

        Still, as master, he was responsible for the operation of the boat.

        McGinnis also faces fines up to $25,000 and cleanup and recovery costs that could exceed several hundred thousand dollars, Lt. Cmdr. Bowen said. A man who answered the phone Tuesday at McGinnis declined comment.

[photo] Robert Page, a deckhand on the Anderson Ferry, saw the Robert M sick Monday
(Michael E. Keating photos)
| ZOOM |
        It could take one to two weeks before the river level drops low enough to safely raise the tow, which is 60 feet long and 22 feet wide.

        With about 20 to 30 feet from the top of the hull to the surface, concern over it being hit by another boat or a barge grows as the river recedes, Lt. Cmdr. Bowen said. A lighted buoy was placed at the site Tuesday and advisories were dispatched.

        It is not known how much of the tow's 3,000 gallons of diesel fuel has leaked. The spill has slowed to “one to two drops per minute” and does not pose an environmental threat because the rain-swollen river has quickly dissipated the fuel.

        While the choppy waters helped minimize the leak, the same condition “definitely contributed” to the boat's sinking, Lt. Cmdr. Bowen said.

[photo] Don Phelps of Anderson Ferry saw the Robert M sink around 5 p.m. Monday.
| ZOOM |
        It was “one of the strangest things I've ever seen,” Anderson Ferry Capt. Don Phelps said as he crossed the river Tuesday, pointing to the point where the Robert M. went down.

        “It looked like something right out of a movie,” he said. “I heard his mayday call on the radio. They said "stay calm' and he said "That's what I'm trying to do.'”

        Mr. Phelps, an 11-year ferry veteran, makes an average of 32 round trips across the river each day, and had never seen a boat sink before.

        The river can look deceptively calm from the riverbank. News of the sinking created concern for some.

        “I was worried,” said Delhi native Ruthy Dew, 73, of Clearwater, Fla., before driving onto the ferry. “But it looks smooth to me.”

OHIO RIVER LEVELS
    • Monday ....... 35' 6”
    • Tuesday ....... 38'
    • Crest by Friday ....... 42'
    • Level needed to safely raise the Robert M. ....... 30-35'
    Source: U.S. Coast Guard

        It wasn't.

        Mr. Phelps called the Ohio “still choppy, but not as bad as last week.”

        An earlier master on the Robert M. reported no problems.

        But when Mr. Roberts came aboard, he told McGinnis there was water in the hull compartment and engine room, and the tow was listing, with a nearly 2.5-foot differential.

        He was told by McGinnis to “dewater,” or pump the water out, Lt. Cmdr. Bowen said.

        Mr. Roberts repeated that process twice more while on the river.

        “The vessel had three hull (leaks) and was listing when he took it at 8:25 a.m.,” Lt. Cmdr. Bowen said. “(The company) agreed with my findings that there was a failure to communicate, a failure in company policy. And they're working to address those.”

        The same tow, then named the Midwestern, sank in 1981 near the Markland Dam in Gallatin County, killing master Virgil Humphrey of Hebron, according to an Enquirer article from June 12, 1981.

       



Archbishop expresses his distress
Census shows SE Indiana perked up by prosperity
'Star Wars' launches at 12:01 a.m.
Local program employs youths for summer jobs
Luken fears tax may spook Convergys
Men still missing after second day of river search
Obituary: Richard J. Schilling owned Beverly Hills
- Pilot license suspended in sinking of towboat
Presbyterians vote to study gay issue
Time Warner stops charging franchise fee
Tristate A.M. Report
AMOS: Bad timing
BRONSON: Roach forum
HOWARD: Some Good News
KORTE: City Hall
Cinergy grants aid area schools
Conese denies threatening board member
Lebanon adds to downtown
Lebanon annexation bid gets nod
Middfest shines spotlight
Planners scale down I-75 mall
Policeman dodges bullets
Portman taking sides now that primary's over
Principal selected for Mason High School
West Chester TV expands programs
5-4 ruling shows rift on court
Convention center tax advances
New game will face updated Powerball
Traficant to play tapes for committee
Edgewood chooses police chief
Kentucky News Briefs
Many tax refund notices undelivered
Power plant conditions set
Protesters air gripes at finance firm's meeting
State works to fix deficit

 

Latest Headline News
Updated Every 30 Minutes
AP TOP HEADLINE NEWS

Iraqi Official: 150,000 Civilians Dead

Sen. Allen Concedes Defeat in Virginia

Bush, Pelosi Hold White House Talks

Massive Recall of Acetaminophen Underway

Mubarak Warns Against Hanging Saddam

Bolton Unlikely to Win Senate Approval

AP: Startling Findings in Tillman Probe

Ed Bradley of '60 Minutes' Dies at 65

U.S. Rises in Auto Reliability Ratings

49ers Look to Relocate New Stadium



Cincinnati.Com
Search our site by keyword:  
Search also: News | Jobs | Homes | Cars | Classifieds | Obits | Coupons | Events | Dining
Movies/DVDs | Video Games | Hotels | Golf | Visitor's Guide | Maps/Directions | Yellow Pages

  CINCINNATI.COM  |  NKY.COM  |  ENQUIRER  |  CIN WEEKLY  |  Classifieds  |  Cars  |  Homes  |  Jobs  |  Help


Search | Questions/help | News tips | Letters to the editors | Subscribe
Newspaper advertising | Web advertising | Place a classified | Circulation

Copyright 1995-2007. The Cincinnati Enquirer, a Gannett Co. Inc. newspaper.
Use of this site signifies agreement to terms of service updated 12/19/2002.