Tuesday, November 06, 2001
Father testifies before jury
By Janice Morse
The Cincinnati Enquirer
HAMILTON Raising a trembling hand to his lips, James Neil Howard tearfully told a jury why he was so upset during a 911 call to a dispatcher: I thought I was losing my little boy.
Mr. Howard's testimony Monday proved to be the most emotional of his five-day trial in Butler County Common Pleas Court. Monday's testimony also included more than an hour from a Massachusetts neurosurgeon hired by the county Children Services Board to render a second medical opinion.
Throughout the case of what is alleged to involve shaken baby syndrome, Mr. Howard, 28, of Hamilton, has said he did nothing to hurt his son, Draven. The child suffered devastating brain and eye injuries during his infancy last year.
The boy's birth in January 2000 followed failed forceps and vacuum-extraction attempts, which doctors have said could account for some of the child's injuries. Prosecutors have argued that Mr. Howard had opportunity to abuse the child on April 1 and April 4, when the child developed serious breathing problems and Mr. Howard was the only adult with him. Mr. Howard is accused of two felony child-endangering charges, each carrying a sentence of up to eight years.
A jury is expected to begin deliberations today after lawyers give their closing arguments.
On Monday, Mr. How ard's lawyer, Michael Shanks, asked him if he ever shook, slammed, punched or abused his child in any way. Shaking his head no, Mr. Howard replied: I did not hurt my son. I love him.
The defense also presented testimony from Eleni Howard, Mr. Howard's adopted daughter. Now 9, the girl had trouble remembering some events, but she said that she never saw her father treat her brother badly.
Dr. Robert C. Cantu, who has been chief of neurosurgery for more than 30 years at Emerson Hospital in Concord, Mass., testified that by the time Draven's head injuries were discovered on April 4, 2000, some brain tissue had died from an unknown previous cause.
The processes that caused it could have dated back weeks or months, or possibly to Draven's birth, Dr. Cantu said.
Dr. Cantu said something had to have occurred prior to (April 1 and April 4) to cause most of the findings in Draven's case.
A number of Dr. Cantu's statements differed from those offered by prosecution witnesses, mostly doctors from Children's Hospital Medical Center who had seen Draven.
Today's election has local focus
Suburbs on city election: Who cares
UC bumps tuition 6% over 2 quarters
Roach's record to be sealed or cleared
Post office checking for anthrax
Suspicious-car report leads to evacuations
Friends of dead girl charged
Music students protest funding split
PULFER: Protecting our right to sleep late
Temple members share 'Wise Words'
Byrd partner claims he stabbed clerk
Cincinnati plans three new high schools
City schools' levies meet budget needs
Good News: Event benefits students
Museum getting touch-up
St. Ignatius makes plan for future
Traffic accidents claim 3 in Butler
City of Hamilton buys building from Corporex
Father testifies before jury
New police station planned
Ross schools plan expansion
Community Center helps reclaim Ky. neighborhoods
Colleges request $1.2 billion
Forest fires ravage land, firefighters and budget
Ohio hospitals recruit nurses from abroad
Traficant campaign fined for late report on finances