Wednesday, October 17, 2001
Neighborhood build-up plans take two views
By Gregory Korte
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Cincinnati has lost 9 percent of its population since 1990. Its homeownership rate at 38 percent is one of the lowest in the nation.
The candidates for mayor agree on the problems facing the city's neighborhoods. But they've come up with starkly different strategies for fixing them.
Courtis Fuller's plan is one of broad strokes and bold-sounding initiatives, such as his Mayor's Turf War on blight.
Charlie Luken, as with most of his platform, focuses on the not-so-sexy details the little things that, if done right, can turn neighborhoods around. Those include a land-banking database, a housing court and an overhauled city zoning code.
One hot-button issue has been subsidized housing.
A proposal by Democratic Councilman John Cranley would, for all practical purposes, impose a moratorium on new low-income housing in the city.
Mr. Luken supports the idea.
If you look at the numbers, one of the things that has happened in College Hill, Westwood and Price Hill is that they're over-impacted by subsidized housing, he said. What I'm saying is, enough is enough.
Mr. Fuller doesn't have a position on the issue. He said he supports efforts to make neighborhoods more stable, but also wants to see them remain inclusive.
Similarly, Mr. Fuller has expressed reservations about attempts to bring upscale housing to poor neighborhoods such as Over-the-Rhine and the West End especially if it means moving poor people out.
Mr. Luken lives just blocks from Laurel Homes, a West End housing project being demolished and rebuilt with the help of a $200 million federal Hope VI grant.
The goal, which Mr. Luken supports enthusiastically, is to replace the projects favored by housing policies of decades past with an integrated neighborhood of 372 rental units and 128 for-purchase homes.
Neighborhoods are only successful if they have a mix of residents of different incomes living together, Mr. Luken said.
But Mr. Fuller is more skeptical. As a television news reporter, he won a statewide journalism award for a story called The Price of Progress, which focused on what happened to the people evicted from Laurel Homes.
Maybe I'm just old-fashioned, Mr. Fuller said. I know mixed-income communities work, but sometimes we study things so much that we over-study them.
While there is Hope VI, there are still a lot of people without hope, because they've been moved out.
Beyond those philosophical differences, the two candidates have practical differences on how best to improve neighborhoods.
Mr. Fuller's plan emphasizes investment:
A Queen City Neighborhood Improvement Initiative would use tax money paid by neighborhoods themselves some from existing taxes and some, if property owners agree, new taxes on improvements there.
An Urban Gateways project to offer low-interest loans to owners along main thoroughfares to improve the outside of their properties.
A restructuring of the city's Building Department to better allow residents to invest in their own homes and businesses.
Mr. Luken's plan emphasizes changes in city government, such as a housing court that would keep better track of landlords.
He also backs employer-assisted down payment programs and the Citirama tour of new homes in the city.
2 guilty in morgue photo case
Amid anthrax scares, local agencies prepare for real thing
Anthrax pranksters face prosecution, Allen says
Fears similar to '62 missile crisis
Feds to audit airport-security firms
Accused boy says he kneed sister
Cranley pushing vote on housing
Fuller, Luken trade barbs over riots and aftermath
Generations spar in ads for city candidates
Money will await some graduates
Neighborhood build-up plans take two views
Political Notebook
Teen pleads guilty in tot's shooting
Tristate A.M. Report
HOWARD: Some Good News
SAMPLES: Clean politics
Clermont County clinic among 90 to get threats
Fight intensifies over hospital move
Hospital plans argued by two jurisdictions
Loveland hires assistant city manager
Mason teacher talks resume
Pupils honor deceased principal
Chao: Existing programs suitable for those in need
Pioneering lawmaker honored
Taft urges increase in taxes
ABA jolts bench hopes
Adult 'zone' discussed
Death-penalty foes get forum
Highlands graduate tested
Madison Theater to unveil face lift
New chief begins with outreach
No vaccine, so flu shots off at present
PETA wants to keep Morrow trainer from regaining license