Saturday, February 10, 2001
Tower owner sues Hamilton
City sues county over water purchase
By Janice Morse and Earnest Winston
The Cincinnati Enquirer
HAMILTON In the midst of a budget crunch and economic downturn, the city's legal fees are multiplying.
One Renaissance Hamilton Inc., the landlord for the city's new $18 million office tower, on Thursday filed suit against the city, seeking back rent totaling more than $600,000 plus legal fees.
The lawsuit in Butler County Common Pleas Court alleges that the city delayed completion and occupancy of the structure, at High Street and Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard, to avoid paying several months' rent.
City Councilman Richard Holzberger said Hamilton has been at odds with its landlord for months; he blames the delays on One Renaissance.
I think they're trying to make another quick buck on us, he said. I think it's frivolous, and I think it will be resolved quickly.
In other legal action, the city on Friday made good on its threat and filed a $2 million-plus lawsuit against Butler County.
Hamilton alleges the county's purchase of water from Cincinnati in 1999 breached the county's 1989 agreement to purchase most of its water from Hamilton until 2021. County leaders say they did nothing wrong because the agreement allows purchase from other sources in emergencies.
The increased litigation comes at a time when Hamilton has been trying to cut expenses and increase revenues to make up for a proj ected $1.5 million shortfall. The city has lost payroll taxes and other revenue after hundreds of jobs were cut recently by two employers: Ohio Casualty Group and International Paper.
The water lawsuit is the latest chapter in the three-year Hamilton-Butler dispute, litigation that has cost the city more than $1 million.
In 1998, the county sued Hamilton, accusing the city of overcharging the county for water rates. A judge threw out the lawsuit in 1999; the county appealed.
The 12th District Court of Appeals in Middletown had been scheduled to hear oral arguments Feb. 20, but the city asked for a two-month delay.
Hamilton says it suffered lost revenue of more than $2 million plus interest; the lawsuit seeks additional damages of at least $25,000.
Winburn steps down from council
Bengals looking to settle seat suit
Pharmacies jockeying for drive-through room
Winds bring damage, outages
Chamber recognizes Cincinnati fixture
Mental-health system criticized
OxyContin use said likely to spread
SAMPLES: Fright sight
UC: Thou shalt do the right thing
Boy's project: surgery
Tower owner sues Hamilton
Vets to receive honorary diplomas
Anti-profiling lawyers team up
Audit: State's foster-care programs need work
Drug raid near Highlands nets 12
Four days in February for the birds
Horse farm's concrete icon missing
HOWARD: Neighborhoods
Immigrant sentenced to 10 years in slaying
Indictments issued in nursing home deaths
Judge allows depositions in mine case
Lebanon seeks way to buy gyms
Mayor orders files held
MCNUTT: Go Bouldering
Montgomery Inn opening in Ft. Mitchell
Mt. St. Joe offers high school honors program
Princeton Pike, Mulhauser crossings due for overhaul
UK president-designate pays calls in Capitol
Vandalism follows portfolio dispute
Kentucky News Briefs
Tristate A.M. Report