Saturday, February 03, 2001
Kenton Co. tax protest suit grows
More of annual wage being taken
By Cindy Schroeder
The Cincinnati Enquirer
COVINGTON More parties have entered the lawsuit challenging Kenton County's recent payroll tax cap increase, saying it guarantees an automatic tax increase each year.
Seco Electric Inc., a Covington electrical contractor; employee Joe Schamer Jr.; and the Greater Cincinnati Building and Trades Council on Friday filed a motion to intervene in the lawsuit filed last week by the city of Covington and Corporex Cos.
Kenton County's payroll tax cap, or the maximum amount of annual salary on which taxes can be collected, was raised from $25,000 to $80,400 on Jan. 1, in line with the Social Security cap. County officials plan to use the additional $5 million in tax revenues to offset the costs of expanding and renovating the crowded jail in downtown Covington.
Joe Schamer Jr., whose family started Seco Electric, said the new cap places an onerous burden on Kenton County workers and businesses.
Essentially, Kenton County Fiscal Court is attempting to impose a hidden tax, Mr. Schamer said. To make matters worse, the county fiscal court is telling us that we don't get a credit for city taxes paid because they did not "increase' our taxes. We're just paying more.
Scott Kimmich, Kenton County deputy judge-executive, referred all questions on the latest challenge of the county's payroll tax cap hike to Sheryl Snyder, a Louisville lawyer who is advising the county on the issue. Mr. Snyder said the fact that the tax is geared to the Social Security maximum does not affect its legality.
Lawyer Mark Guilfoyle, who filed Friday's action with co-counsel Patrick Hughes, described the annual tax increase as the county's dirty little secret.
Tying its tax cap to the Social Security maximum guarantees a tax increase every year, Mr. Guilfoyle said. This year, the Social Security cap went from $76,000 to $80,400.
Over the last four years, the Social Security maximum has increased by $15,000, Mr. Hughes said. We believe the county's payroll tax scheme is arbitrary and capricious and in violation of the Kentucky Constitution.
Covington's suit asks a Kenton Circuit Court judge to determine whether the new taxes collected by the county would be subject to tax credits, which would enable workers to credit city payroll taxes against county taxes.
Under legislation passed last year, any new payroll tax or increase after Jan. 1, 2000, would be subject to tax credits.
Powerball wants to add Ohio
Accomplice disputes killer's death-row appeal
County punishes probation officers
Judge's double-dipping called legal
NKU homecoming king needn't be he
'Senioritis' can cheat students' futures
Tailpipe deal may be struck for Ky.
New hormone-replacer called better
Ross High teen wins $20,000
SAMPLES: Land-grab law used unfairly
Thomas More reopens search for president
Westbound FWW to close for repair
Guard dies, 4 injured in prison van crash
Budget 'clouds' loom for mental health
Bunning, Lucas get assignments
Cabby wants city to let him deliver flowers
Child alerts family to flames in house
Common Pleas gains 2 judges
Defendants indicted in 3 cases
HOWARD: Hardee's helps with heat bills
Ice sends cars skidding
Kenton Co. tax protest suit grows
Two on Mason council to step down
With year to go, attorney's race heats up
Coal firm would reopen pond that spilled
Paducah exposure records incomplete
Prosecutor: No evidence of hazing