Tuesday, October 03, 2000
Sports bias suit fails
Sports case turned down
By Laurie Asseo
The Associated Press
WASHINGTON The Supreme Court refused on Monday to revive a lawsuit that said Kentucky high schools discriminated against female athletes by not offering interscholastic fast-pitch softball.
The court, without comment, turned down arguments by the students, who have since graduated, that they should be allowed to collect financial damages even without proof of intentional discrimination.
The four former Louisville students were among 12 girls who sued the Kentucky High School Athletic Association and the state school board in 1992.
The lawsuit said school officials' failure to sanction fast-pitch softball as an interscholastic sport violated Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, which bans sex discrimination in schools that receive federal money.
Standard of evidence
At the time, slow-pitch softball was the only form of the sport generally available to high school girls in Kentucky. During the mid-1990s state legislators voted to require any school offering slow-pitch softball to also include fast-pitch, and now most Kentucky schools offer fast-pitch softball for female athletes.
The lawsuit sought financial damages for the loss of opportunities for the female students, but a federal judge ruled against them. The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed last March, saying the students did not show the federal law's equal opportunity mandate had been violated.
Even if they had shown such a violation, the appeals court said, the students also must show intentional discrimination before they could collect damages.
Lawyers for the athletic association and school board said the students would be unable to meet either standard.
Port authority plan passes final hurdles
Port Authority proposal details
Cheney here for debate, ribs
Watch the debate and tell us what you think
Boater on trial for 3 deaths
Cat lady's death may bring new charges
PULFER: Mystery clerk aims to please
Ten Commandments backers see many signs of support
Wilmington teacher named tops in Ohio
CPS board extends superintendent's contract
Elections worker quits amid probe
Enquirer subscriptions increase Nov. 1
Man runs as fire blazes
Man sues after 92 days in jail without trial
Drug suspects recalled as good students
Jail dispute leads to early exits
Mason hires temporary fire chief
Mason moves against sex businesses
Life in Tristate is under scrutiny
Ohio school money studied
Pupils gain interest in new school bank
Sports bias suit fails
Woman, 18, charged in Mt. Washington slaying
Woman's conviction overturned in death of motorcyclist
$4.5M saved on stadium
Wife killer sentenced: 'I know I have to pay'