Wednesday, August 02, 2000
Death puts shadow on park image
Police report arrests largely alcohol-related
By Terry Flynn
The Cincinnati Enquirer
NEWPORT The recent death of an elderly man who was severely beaten in the public restroom at James Taylor Park has heightened the public perception that the park is a hangout for gay men and prostitutes.
Members of Stonewall Cincinnati, the local human rights organization that focuses on the gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender community, claim Newport police are targeting gay men in the park.
POLICE OFFICER PAUL KUNKEL PLACES HANDCUFFS ON A MAN TUESDAY AFTER ARRESTING HIM FOR PUBLIC INTOXICATION IN JAMES TAYLOR PARK IN NEWPORT.|
(Patrick Reddy photo)
| ZOOM |
Police officials say that is not the case, producing arrest records compiled over the past 18 months that show a preponderance of arrests for alcohol-related offenses. Out of 37 arrests, two were females. The lone prostitution arrest was a 19-year-old man.
The tragedy that produced discussion of park safety in Newport City Commission meetings occurred June 5 when 80-year-old Eugene Schulkers of Dayton was beaten and kicked so brutally in the restroom at James Taylor Park that his neck was broken. He died in the hospital nine days later.
The man charged in Mr. Schulkers' death, 21-year-old Thomas Back of Covington, told police that the victim made a remark in the restroom which enraged him.
Originally charged with murder, he was indicted on the lesser charge of manslaughter in what the grand jury described as extreme emotional disturbance.
Police Chief Tom Fromme, who was asked during a recent city commission meeting to determine whether more police presence was needed in the park after Mr. Schulkers' death, said he doesn't think there is a problem.
Predators strike everywhere, the chief said. The number and type of arrests made in the park pretty much mirror what happens in the rest of the city. We patrol the park, but there are no special details there.
Doreen Cudnik, executive director of Stonewall Cincinnati, said Tuesday that she had received a call from a gay man who claimed that there was police harassment in the park.
The man said he visited the park regularly, because he liked to sit on the floodwall and watch the river, she said. James Taylor Park is on the point where the Licking River empties into the Ohio River.
Here are the number and type of arrests in James Taylor Park from January 1999 to July 2000. |
Total arrests: 37.
Open warrants: 4.
Parole violation: 1.
Criminal trespass: 2.
Unlawful use of invalid license, no insurance: 1.
Disorderly conduct: 2.
Marijuana possession: 1.
Ms. Cudnik said the man said he had witnessed Newport police approaching single men or men in pairs and advising them to leave the park. He said, however, he had not personally been confronted in that manner.
It's a touchy issue, Ms. Cudnik said. Not every gay person in a park is there to engage in illegal sex activities. Our concern is keeping people safe, and not being judgmental about their choices. As an organization, we want to keep everyone educated and as safe as possible.
City Commissioner Ken Rechtin, who is a regular visitor to the park with his wife, Tina, said he isn't certain how serious the situation is.
When we are there, there seem to be a lot of people obviously not there to just enjoy the park, he said. There are a lot of transients, and people who give the impression they are looking for something or someone.
There are a lot of cars. We'll see the same car come through, circle through the park, leave, then a few minutes later it will come back and do the same thing.
Asked whether he had received complaints from Newport residents about activities in the park, he replied, You get comments from people like "You know what goes on down there.' But nothing really specific.
Mr. Rechtin said he thinks the park could be utilized much more than it is, with more events like the recent Arts and Music Festival which proved to be more successful in the park than it had been on the nearby city streets.
We used to have a kids fishing derby there, he said. There's a shelter that can be rented free of charge. I think bringing more people to the park regularly will discourage the people who are there to break the law.
Traffic relief in sight
UC Med Center boosts economy
Other big economic engines
Call to 911: 'I just shot my husband'
Gattermeyer to continue Holcomb's legacy
SAMPLES: Pig snub
Communities lend support to police
Details emerge in Craven killing
Readers split on survivors
KIESEWETTER: Teens on 'real' show stress how real it is
'Abracadabra' pulls all new cast out of the hat
City may improve retiree benefits
CONCERT REVIEW: Crowd, Walker combine for good show
Death puts shadow on park image
Coach will form religious group
Columbus school board member sues colleagues
Commissioners blast 2-tier water rate plan
Dayton's top cop retires suddenly
Gray goes beyond Mars and Venus
Hamilton Co. fair under way
Hospital closing causes concern
Ludlow road paving stopped
Middletown schools seek $71M for plan
Organizations benefit from $13.2 million gift
Park to mark history of VOA
Residents try to keep their chief of police
Teen mom may be tried as adult
Trial in teen sexual-assault case to be conducted in secret
Workers find dead woman
Get to it
Pig Parade: Jimmy Boar-fett
Tristate A.M. Report