Wednesday, March 01, 2000

Doan loses appeal


Verdict upheld in murder of girlfriend

BY STEVE KEMME
The Cincinnati Enquirer

        MIDDLETOWN — An appeals court has upheld the conviction of Vincent Doan for kidnapping and killing his girlfriend, Carrie Culberson.

        In a case that attracted national attention, a Clinton County Common Pleas Court jury convicted Mr. Doan in 1997 of aggravated murder and was sentenced to life in prison.

        Ms. Culberson, 22, of Blanchester, disappeared in August 1996, and Mr. Doan was the last person seen with her. Her body was never found.

        Mr. Doan's attorneys contended that he deserved a new trial, saying common pleas court made 11 errors.

        But all three 12th District Court of Appeals judges who reviewed the case ruled this week that Mr. Doan received a fair trial and that the evidence supported his conviction.

        “We're all very happy,” said Ms. Culberson's mother, Debbie Culberson. “I just thank God it turned out the way that it did.”

        Mr. Doan's attorneys said they will appeal the ruling to the Ohio Supreme Court.

        “Obviously I'm very disappointed by that decision,” said Kort Gatterdam, a public defender representing Mr. Doan in the appeal. “We're in this for the duration. We're going to go as far as we have to go to get Mr. Doan a new trial.”

        Ms. Culberson and Mr. Doan had a tempestuous relationship, according to several witnesses who testified in the trial. Mr. Doan beat her on several occasions, they said.

        His brother, Tracy Baker, is serving an eight-year prison sentence for helping cover up the crime. He has appealed his conviction to the 12th District Court of Appeals, but the court hasn't ruled yet.

        Lori Baker, who was living with her ex-husband, Tracy Baker, testified that Mr. Doan came to their house in the early morning hours of Aug. 29 covered with blood and wearing only a pair of jeans.

        She said Mr. Doan and Mr. Baker left the house with garbage bags and a gun.

        Priscilla Doan, Vincent Doan's mother, said she doesn't understand the basis for the appeals court decision.

        “There's no evidence, nothing,” she said. “Everything was hearsay. Hopefully, when we go to the next level, it'll turn out differently. We know our boys are innocent.”

       



Bush to Ohio: Help nail down nomination
Poll: McCain gaining, but still trails in Ohio
Bauer: McCain went too far in criticizing religious leaders
High school kids ask Bush tough questions
$710,000 stadium change OK'd in secret
Prosecutor's office seeks to throw out suit vs. county
Schools' grades higher on latest report cards
Grades for area districts
Criteria for School District Report Card
Troubled districts plot improvement
Students learn how to measure true success
Black studies gains status
- Doan loses appeal
Judge protects inmate money
Reverend faces four counts of molesting 2 boys
Ruling 'death blow' to landfill
As McCain shines, GOP looks away
The gospel according to Andy Griffith
PBS pledge programs carefully aim for emotions
GET TO IT
Museum city has tiny population
Bethel cook runner-up in Bake-Off
Drug trial under way
Florence street study delayed
Franklin motel called firetrap, ordered closed
Grand jury to hear jail knife case
Kids plan leadership quest
Kids study tobacco advertising
Mason schools: We need more yet
MRDD gets interim leader
New park will cover 150 acres
Schools effort fights rumors
Sewer plant plans surveyed
Traffic tops Harrison Twp. beefs
TRISTATE DIGEST
Turfway races spring
Vote negates ethics ruling on Derby tickets
Warren puts 200 years on CDs, film
Women's club plans to renovate landmark