Sunday, February 06, 2000

Tenth is a journey into Mahler's mind




BY JANELLE GELFAND
The Cincinnati Enquirer

        When Mahler died in 1911, he left his Symphony No. 10 unfinished, with only the first movement and part of the third completely orchestrated.

        A number of musicians have attempted to create performing editions of the Tenth, a sprawling 75-minute work in five movements. On Friday, the Cincinnati Symphony Orchestra performed the American premiere of the latest version, which will be recorded by Telarc on Monday.

        After a first hearing of the version prepared by Remo Mazzetti Jr., my question echoes the one posed by musicologist Deryck Cooke, who made the landmark edition recorded by Eugene Ormandy in 1965: “Does (Mahler's) fairly comprehensive sketch of it, put into score by other hands, provide a Mahlerian experience of any real value?”

        There are times when Mr. Mazzetti captures the Mahlerian world perfectly, as in the muted, atmospheric third movement, with its chortling winds. But the movement ends so abruptly, one wonders whether Mahler would have changed it.

        “No one could complete the symphony the way Mahler would have,” said Mr. Mazzetti, 43, by phone from Wilmington, Del. “For the editors who came later, it's an editorial process.” Mr. Mazzetti's first attempt was recorded by Leonard Slatkin and the St. Louis Symphony. For this version, he thinned out the orchestration and made other subtle changes.

        Although not as bleakly pessimistic as the Sixth, the Tenth is an emotional journey, borne out of despair for the composer's troubled marriage and his fear of death. It ends with a sense of resignation.

        Jesus Lopez-Cobos led a performance that was involving, but sometimes lacked intensity. Still, this is powerful music, and the effort warmly applauded by the audience of 1,874.

        The Adagio, with its sweeping strings and brass outbursts, ended with a beautifully phrased reverie in the winds. The second movement, an exuberant scherzo, had a radiant Austrian landler at its center.

        Mr. Mazzetti's drum strokes in the finale are jolting crashes, detracting from the serenity of the strings. Otherwise, the tone world seemed authentic, and the finale enhanced by a memorable horn solo from Robin Graham.

        The program opened with a subdued performance of Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 24 in C Minor, K. 491, with pianist Christian Zacharias. Mr. Zacharias, who is also a conductor (he will succeed Mr. Lopez-Cobos at the Lausanne Chamber Orchestra next year), is a fluid pianist with a sensitive touch and a fine technique.

        However, his tempos were on the slow side, he overpedaled and he favored a lot of unnecessary rubato in his phrasing. His interesting first movement cadenza, of his own invention, had interjections from the winds, separated by pianistic outbursts.

        Tone production and well-chosen tempos can make the difference between a good performance and a sublime one. This one was merely good.

       



Virtual University clicks for students
'Why did police shoot my son?'
Last look at Carpenter shooting
Ohio not impossible dream for McCain
Closing door on Bethesda's 102 years
Better late than never
Deal might stymie rail station
Neighbors now top concern of rail planners
Last school dash greeted with joy, trepidation
Sprawl boosting water bills
Casinos watch security
Queen City's moments to shine reflected in book
Bauer ends run with style
NKU student dies in sand bin at plant
Salon star a real draw
'Wit' role under her skin
Ballet stages wickedly fun 'Musketeers'
Bio sings Marian Anderson's praises
Book fair spotlights young black writers
Cammy tickets on sale Monday
Cincinnatian was friend of famous concert singer
Exhibit links art, blindness
GET TO IT
'Going to do it,' writer says as he takes the plunge
He's partyin' like he's 60
- Tenth is a journey into Mahler's mind
This is no little teapot, short and stout
Dr. King's dream deferred
Butler County native makes sweet music in Hollywood
Avenue to open way for offices
Double celling considered for Warren jail
House candidate just moved to Ky.
Juvenile-justice reform in jeopardy
Kentucky legislators get earful on issues
Mayors take marrying to heart
Newport retools plan for housing
Traficant steels himself against legal, political challenges
TRISTATE DIGEST