Tuesday, January 25, 2000

Owner told to pay double deposits

Lack of heat forced tenants out last year

The Cincinnati Enquirer

        A Mount Airy apartment complex owner has been ordered to pay seven former tenants double their security deposits plus attorney's fees, more than a year after failing to provide enough heat for them.

        Hamilton County Common Pleas Judge Patrick Dinkelacker's ruling Monday will cost Michael J. Davis and his company, Castlerock Properties, an estimated $8,152.

        Former tenants said it's been a long wait for the money. Last year, city officials ordered them to vacate their homes because of the inade quate heat in bitter cold temperatures.

        Attorney Bruce Knabe argued that Mr. Davis and Castlerock Properties shouldn't have to pay double the security deposits because it took some tenants as long as six months to provide forwarding addresses.

        But Robert Newman, the tenants' attorney, argued he gave Mr. Davis forwarding addresses in September as part of the lawsuit and that Mr. Davis and Castlerock employees had forwarding addresses for his clients well before that.

        Mr. Knabe argued that it's difficult to return money in the middle of a lawsuit.

        Judge Dinkelacker said the money should have been returned once Mr. Davis and Castlerock got the addresses.

        Mr. Davis has the option of appealing the judge's ruling.

        Nearly 100 tenants of the Hawaiian Terrace complex were ordered to leave their apartments last January because of insufficient heat.

        Penny and Bruce Eden, who now live in Springdale with their 5-year-old son, were among those who sued.

        “They said in their own responses that the apartment was left in good condition,” Ms. Eden said.

        “With us having a young son like we did, we had to leave.”

        The tenants will try to recover damages from Mr. Davis and Castlerock at a trial next month.

        Judge Dinkelacker ruled Monday that they can't seek punitive damages.


CPS endorses 3 charter schools
CPS teachers may walk
Search ends with CSO landing its choice
'Chemistry' drew new maestro
CSO is what he was looking for
Santa photo sparks nice, naughty claims
Crossroads turns corner with HQ buy
Bauer's hard work may be for naught
$186M more for higher ed
Death of recent grad stuns Lakota
Few know CPR here, study finds
Moment of anguish; momentous decision
Officials share ideas on gangs
Sizing up schools tricky
The kid can play
'Gay-frat' tag source of disagreement
Norwood Boxing Club may get new home - in Norwood
Dressing warm may be challenge this week
Firefighter charged with DUI
Man pleads guilty in fatal robbery
Mason Council OKs police deal
Monmouth St. signs may face curbs
Older adults' WMKV-FM going on Web
- Owner told to pay double deposits
Sierra Club: Air still dirty
Anti-drug group upset by inquiry
Chanticleer choir captures full cathedral
Fair to highlight community service
Few want back on children's board
Guilty plea in endangerment
Kentucky filmmaker tells 'difficult' story
Local man faces attempted murder charge
Men indicted in holdup, assault cases