Wednesday, January 19, 2000
Methadone clinic foes state case
Backers also testify in Covington trial
BY SUSAN VELA
The Cincinnati Enquirer
COVINGTON A former business leader testified Tuesday it wasn't moral concerns that drove him to fight a Pittsburgh-based group's bid to open a methadone clinic more than two years ago.
Patrick Lance, formerly of the Covington Business Council, acknowledged that the concerns of residents, a Covington police officer and his fellow business owners weighed into his decision to suggest more restrictive zoning as a means of keeping methadone clinics and unsavory businesses out of Covington. But he emphasized twice that his morals were not a factor.
It seems like it, countered David Davidson, one of two attorneys representing MX Group Inc. in the federal trial pitting the company and the city of Covington.
MX Group Inc. brought suit after the city rejected its plans for a methadone clinic on West Pike Street near Carlisle Elementary School. The clinic met heavy opposition from residents, Covington police and business owners. The city subsequently eliminated zoning for methadone clinics.
The lawsuit claimed the city of Covington did not afford MX due process of law and violated the federal Americans with Disabilities Act in its efforts to keep MX from serving those disabled by their addictions.
Methadone is used to wean addicts from heroin, pain killers and other opiates.
Protesters said they didn't want recovering drug addicts frequenting that area, that the clinic could lead to increased crime and that its proximity to the school would be bad for children.
After hearing their criticism, the city's board of adjustments overruled a decision by former Zoning Administrator Ralph Hopper. He already had told MX its proposal met local zoning codes.
Steve McMurtry is representing the city. He said Tuesday that companies wanting to operate methadone clinics in Covington can still do so by pursuing a change to the city's zoning plan.
Such an amendment would not be site specific. Instead, it would be to all zones of a certain type. Many businesses have been successful with this tactic, he said.
U.S. District Judge William O. Bertelsman said the case ultimately will boil down to this question: Can the city bar all activity of a particular kind. Today, he will hear witnesses testify on behalf of Covington. He is expected to issue a ruling within four months.
MX is asking for injunctive relief or, as MX attorney William Oldfield said, to be treated like any other clinic.
At Tuesday's proceedings, five witnesses testified on MX's behalf. They included Mr. Hopper, Mr. Lance and Melissa Fabian, a Fort Wright resident who had worked to open the MX facility in Covington.
Ms. Fabian noted that MX chose the Pike Street site because it was the most accessible, available and affordable.
She recalled public hearings at which residents protested MX's plans. They didn't want to hear the full details, she said. Many, she said, wanted to talk about the proposal's proximity to the elementary school and how they wouldn't feel safe letting their school-age children walk past the clinic.
My impression was that there was a lot of anger, she said. there was a lot of yelling (and) almost personal attacks like, how would I like this in my neighborhood?
She didn't deny that methadone has side effects on drug addicts, including restlessness, faintness and dry mouth. But, she said, the positive outcomes far outweigh the negative ones.
Tristate health little improved
Let's throw a party to rededicate the Fountain
More snow expected tonight
Taft to push teacher training
Ads waste $33 million, critics say
Reds 'ballpark figure' just that
Auditor-prosecutor fight now a federal case
Five bundles of joy arrive
Hyland stays in fight vs. Portune
Love passes on jury
Police, fire unions plan to battle city over 2% cuts
Bill would abolish car tailpipe test
Queen City's moments to shine reflected in book
Tax credit for non-public school kids revisited in Ky.
Trauma-care system draws interest, support
King events continue today
Mercantile movin' on up
'ER' undergoes surgery for post-Clooney slump
'Felicity' star's new do doesn't work
GET TO IT
'The Woolgatherer' a riveting production
Bill would cut EMTs' retraining
Brookville man dies in house fire
Coroner's reports cloud Sheppard case
Educators want to improve future teachers
Fairfield's school chief has 15 goals for 5 years
GOP challenger unqualified for Kenton court clerk's job
Ind. suspect jumps to his death
Indiana council member apologizes for racial slur
Methadone clinic foes state case
Road renamed 'Tim Couch Pass'
School districts resolve boundary dispute
Sound off on road connection
Storied Calumet focus of trial
Townships' leaders brought together