Thursday, June 24, 1999
Fen-phen settlement monitored
Hundreds locally have filed suits
BY SUSAN VELA
The Cincinnati Enquirer
The settlement of a lawsuit in Texas this week bears promise for hundreds of others that have been filed by Tristate residents against Ameri can Home Products Corp., a Madison, N.J.-based company and maker of half of the once-popular diet drug fen-phen.
It shows that when there's a serious case, they're settling, said Stanley M. Chesley, a Cincinnati class-
action specialist and co-chairman of an 11-member team representing people suing the makers of fen-phen diet drugs.
He added that about 3,500 lawsuits nationwide, including several hundred from the Tris tate area, have been filed against American Home Products (AHP).
On the one hand, they keep denying responsibility, he said. On the other hand, when they face a jury, they settle. (And) they're usually settling on the courthouse steps.
There's no question this was a dangerous drug. A lot who thought they did not have a good case (now) will come forward.
AHP's drug division Wyeth-Ayerst Laboratories is known as the maker of Pondimin a brand name for fenfluramine, the fen portion of fen-phen. AHP has been the target of a flurry of lawsuits since September 1997, when the U.S. Food and Drug Administration pulled fenfluramine from the market because of evidence that it may have scarred users' heart valves irreversibly and sometimes fatally.
Phentermine, the other half of fen-phen, has not been linked to illness. About 6.6 million people have used the diet drug combination. Riverfront Diet Clinic of Covington had about 2,200 people enrolled in its 1996 fen-phen program. Most were from Ohio.
People from surrounding states were flocking to Kentucky to get fen-phen. Tennessee had banned its use, Ohio allowed prescriptions for only 12 weeks and Indiana had a 30-day restriction.
Charlie Murdock, 66, of Symmes Township, has been a little shocked to see all of the litigation filed against AHP. He has no regrets about taking fen-phen while he was a Riverfront client about two years ago. He stopped only when his family doctor told him about critical studies on the drug.
I have no regrets, he said. It did work very well for me. Most of the lawsuits filed against AHP are federal cases and have been consolidated in U.S. District Court in Philadelphia, where Judge Louis C. Bechtle is overseeing all trial preparation and any settlements. Those cases are now in a pre-trial evidence stage.
The state cases began to go to trial earlier this year. AHP settled the first case April 8, agreeing to pay $500,000. It was a nonfatal case.
The second settlement came Tuesday. It was a wrongful-death suit, in which the relatives of Mary Marisa Smith contended that use of fen-phen had killed the woman at 35. AHP has not disclosed the amount of settlement.
Meanwhile, Lexington attorney David Helmers concurs that the settlements indicate the worth of these cases. He is one of three attorneys involved in a lawsuit that has received class-action certification in Boone Circuit Court. AHP, Bariatrics Inc. of Kentucky and Dr. W. Rex Duff of Ashland are the defendants.
The lawsuit states that the defendants are responsible for many people not receiving adequate warnings.
They trusted these companies and the physicians ... and now they're scared to death and rightfully so, Mr. Helmers said. The bottom line is that the individuals who took these drugs have suffered threats of injury.
Meanwhile, Dr. Fortune Williams of the Riverfront Diet Clinic in Covington has a different opinion. He said Riverfront has not been involved in any of the fen-phen cases.
He thinks those cases arose from people who were taking more than 80 milligrams of Pondimin a day. Riverfront clients were taking between 20 and 40 milligrams, he said.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Fernald health concerns increase
Railroad killings put Tristate on lookout
Suspect in killings is disguise master
Panel to review police conduct
How complaint against a police officer works
Putting a fresh face on GOP
Airwaves carry host beyond his disability
Cincinnati schools get increase of $13 million
City investigates church collapse
Downtown's peregrine falcons have flown the coop
Fen-phen settlement monitored
'Full speed ahead' for tailpipe test
Emissions check will cost $20
Local lawmaker faults EPA
Parched, smoggy Tristate looks forward to some rain
Pool caused rash, patrons tell city
Schools look at district transfers
Video could free man of sex charge
Boone Co. can afford to say no to mine
Star Trek Earth Tour lands here Friday
Sons do dads proud on Father's Day
GET TO IT
Lebanon native opera's rising star
Roeding golf outing nails the green
2 charged with robbery, abduction
Attempted rape case dropped
Bicyclist's death might not have been from crash
Boy dies week after near-drowning
Cable providers OK under budget
Campbell Co. tightens belt
Cheaper calls a step closer
City may bill landlords for unruly-tenant calls
Colerain Connector won't die
Hamilton grows its own school leaders
Hamilton mayor to tell Senate that clean-air plan's too tough
Housing starts could set record
Kramer promises court office upgrade
Norwood has a new police boss
Police say Ohio man used Net to solicit sex with girl
Second Street model shows car, bus lanes
Shared rides to cost less, be expanded
Temp teacher program expands
This camp celebrates old age, youth
Walk celebrates Germans