Catholic bishops: Priesthood not appropriate for females

Thursday, October 15, 1998

Gannett News Service

WASHINGTON -- Saying they were "painfully aware" of disagreement on the subject, U.S. bishops this week told American Catholics that ordaining female priests is out of the question because Jesus Christ's apostles were all males.

"Ordination to the ministerial priesthood is reserved to men," said a document released by the National Conference of Catholic Bishops' doctrine committee, "because the Church is bound to follow the example of the Lord, who chose only men as his apostles."

The priesthood document, titled "Ten Frequently Asked Questions about the Reservation of Priestly Ordination to Men," offered no prospect for further study that might reopen the issue.

Noting that Pope John Paul II invoked papal infallibility in restating the church's position on a males-only

priesthood, the bishops said, "The church must follow the example of Christ, who called women to discipleship but not to membership in the Twelve."

While emphatically closing the door on a female priesthood, the U.S. bishops' doctrinal committee, headed by Cincinnati Archbishop Daniel Pilarczyk, said it was "painfully aware" that some U.S. Catholics disagree.

"These differences present obstacles along the way toward unity among us," it acknowledged.

But the church's teaching "must be accepted in faith," the document concluded. The doctrine of male-only priesthood, it said, is "discerned and explained" by the church from Christ's teachings and "not invented or generated on her own authority."

Several other faiths have ordained female priests and ministers, and the Roman Catholic bishops admitted the issue has become a roadblock to closer ties with other faiths.

The male-only priesthood wasn't meant as an affront to women, the committee hastened to add, explaining that "the church has clearly affirmed the equal dignity of men and women."

Local Headlines For Thursday, October 15, 1998

A sporting event that has it all
Bequest among Miami's largest
Broadway stars stage CCM tribute
Catholic bishops: Priesthood not appropriate for females
Cinergy to give $3M for schools
City schools risk large deficit
Dearborn juggles funds to pay shortfall
Female police officer killed in Harrodsburg
Ft. Wright candidates offer plans, experience
Golden Galaxies honor students
Homicides drain county budget for public defenders
Lawyer for the little guys
Lebanon reaches cable settlement
Lighthouse searches for visionary youths
Lincoln Heights cop charged in ATM theft
Man's sexuality may be linked to slaying
Managed-care health plans called unfair to black doctors
Mine risks reached to surface
Minority, local work on stadium questioned
North Bend proposed as bridge site
Pink-ribboned soap carries vital message
Plain talk about race and rights
Political bugs, sludge, smiles, frowns and calms
Portune urges revising hate-crime law to protect gays
Pumpkin plundering adds to shortage
School split fact sheet draws anger
Southgate losing piece of its soul
Taft, Fisher agree to debates
Tavares, Blackwell politely spar
Teens plead not guilty in man's death
Warren votes 3-2 against landfill
Wife is guilty of neglect, not death
Work to shut some ramps to Fort Washington Way
Xavier, St. X get donation of $8M
Zoo adds more trunk space